Two Bites at the Same Apple? ?Derivative' ISDS Proceedings in the Revised Korea-US FTA

Author:Jaemin Lee
Position:Professor of International Law at Seoul National University School of Law, Korea. LL.B./LL.M./Ph.D.(SNU), J.D.(Boston College), LL.M.(Georgetown). ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4738-6583. The author may be contacted at: jaemin@snu.ac.kr / Address: Seoul National University School of Law 1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul 08826 Korea.
Pages:107-130
SUMMARY

The 2018 amendment of the KORUS has made an important stride in the investment chapter of the agreement. In particular, the amendment introduced new provisions to regulate multiple, subsequent or parallel ISDS proceedings involving the same governmental measures. The new provisions, however, arguably contain inherent limitations. They will be able to address only some of the multiple, subsequent... (see full summary)

 
FREE EXCERPT
Jaemin Lee
The 2018 amendment of the KORUS has made an important stride in the investment
chapter of the agreement. In particular, the amendment introduced new provisions
to regulate multiple, subsequent or parallel ISDS proceedings involving the same
governmental measures. The new provisions, however, arguably contain inherent
limitations. They will be able to address only some of the multiple, subsequent or
parallel proceedings. They then leave open a possibility where essentially the same
investor raises a series of ISDS proceedings against essentially the same measures by
an advance planning on the scope of measures and/or form of control. This means
that the new provisions will not be able to fully prevent multiple, subsequent or parallel
proceedings in the same context or circumstances from taking place, as was originally
intended by the drafters. More detailed wordings and elaborations would have helped
to achieve the objective. Future Joint Committee discussions or additional amendments

Keywords
Investment Arbitration, ISDS Proceedings, ISDS Reform, Korea-US FTA,
Parallel Proceedings, Subsequent Proceedings, Multiple Proceedings
Professor of International Law at Seoul National University School of Law, Korea. LL.B./LL.M./Ph.D.(SNU),
J.D.(Boston College), LL.M.(Georgetown). ORCID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4738-6583. The author may be
contacted at: jaemin@snu.ac.kr / Address: Seoul National University School of Law 1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul
08826 Korea.
Two Bites at the Same
Apple? Derivative ISDS
Proceedings in the Revised
Korea-US FTA
J. EAST ASIA & INTL L. Vol. 12/No.1 (2019); 107-130
Publication type : Research Article
Section : Regional Focus & Controversies
DOI : http://dx.doi.org/10.14330/jeail.2019.12.1.06
108 Jaemin Lee
1. KORUS Amendment and the Investment Chapter
The Republic of Korea and the United States of America (US) concluded a Free
Trade Agreement (FTA) on March 15, 2012.
1
Among many features contained
in the FTA, the investment arbitration (Investor-State Dispute Settlement: ISDS)
proceedings set forth in Chapter 11 of the Agreement turned out to be one of the
stickiest and most controversial issues.
2
Since then, many observers have been closely
watching how the ISDS mechanism in the Korea-US FTA (KORUS)
3
is applied and
implemented in practice. The level of interest and concern has ratcheted up with the

4
In September 2017, at the request of the Trump Administration of the US, the
two countries initiated negotiations to amend the KORUS.
5
  
     
countries domestic procedures, the amended KORUS went into effect on January 1,
2019.
6
Major areas so amended are: (i) enhanced US access to the Korean automobile
market
7
; (ii) improvement of procedures to verify countries of origin under the
1 Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR), US - Korea Free Trade Agreement, available at https://ustr.
gov/trade-agreements/free-trade-agreements/korus-fta (last visited on Mar. 16 2019).
2 In many countries, the investment arbitration mechanism has become one of the most important issues in any BIT
discussion and negotiation. See UNCITRAL, Report of Working Group III (Investor-State Dispute Settlement Reform)
on the work of its thirty-fourth session (Vienna, Nov. 27-Dec. 1, 2017), U.N. Doc. A/CN.9/930/Add.1/Rev.1, 51st
session (June 25-July 13, 2018). This mechanism began to draw global attention starting from late 1990s. See J.
JACKSON, M. BRONCKERS & R. QUICK, NEW DIRECTIONS IN INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC LAW: ESSAYS IN HONOUR OF JOHN H.
JACKSON 392-3 (2000).
3 The full text of the Korea-US FTA is available at http://www.fta.go.kr/us/doc/1 (last visited on Mar. 16, 2019).
4 Since 2012, seven cases have been submitted for ISDS proceedings against the government of the Republic of Korea
under various IIAs (as of Mar. 16 2019). Three of them are filed by the US investors under the KORUS. The three
proceedings were all raised in 2018. They are Elliott Associates, L.P. v. Republic of Korea; Mason Capital L.P. and
Mason Management LLC v. Republic of Korea (PCA Case No. 2018-55); and Jin Hae Seo v. Republic of Korea. See
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (“UNCTAD”), Investment Dispute Navigator, Korea, Republic
of – As Respondent, available at https://investmentpolicyhub.unctad.org/ISDS/CountryCases/111?partyRole=2 (last
visited on Mar. 16, 2019).
5 USTR, Statement on the Conclusion of US-Korea (KORUS) FTA Meetings in Seoul (Jan. 2, 2018), available at https://
ustr.gov/about-us/policy-offices/press-office/fact-sheets/2018/january/statement-conclusion-us-korea-korus-0; For an
overview of the renegotiation, see B. Williams et al., US-South Korea (KORUS) FTA, CRS REP.: IN FOCUS (Dec. 28,
2018), available at https://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/IF10733.pdf (last visited on Mar. 16, 2019).
6 Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, Korea’s National Assembly Ratifies Revised KORUS FTA (Dec. 7, 2018),
available at http://english.motie.go.kr/en/pc/pressreleases/bbs/bbsView.do?bbs_cd_n=2&bbs_seq_n=685 (last visited
on Mar. 16, 2019).
7 USTR, Fact Sheet on US-Korea Free Trade Agreement Outcomes, (Sept. 2018), available at https://ustr.gov/about-us/
policy-offices/press-office/fact-sheets/2018/september/fact-sheet-us-korea-free-trade (last visited on Mar. 16, 2019).

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR TRIAL