Risks, Regulations, and Impacts of FinTech Adoption on Commercial Banks in the United States and Canada: A Comparative Analysis
| Published date | 01 November 2024 |
| Author | Lamia Kalai,Mohamed Toukabri |
| Date | 01 November 2024 |
| DOI | http://doi.org/10.1002/tie.22404 |
Thunderbird International Business Review, 2024; 66:609–641
https://doi.org/10.1002/tie.22404
609
Thunderbird International Business Review
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Risks, Regulations, and Impacts of FinTech Adoption on
Commercial Banks in the United States and Canada: A
Comparative Analysis
LamiaKalai1 | MohamedToukabri2
1Faculté des Sciences E conomiques et de Gestion de Tunis , Université de Tunis El Man ar, Tunis, Tunis ia | 2Department of Busine ss, College of Arts and
Science Dhahran A l Janoub, King Khalid Uni versity, Abha, Saudi Arabia
Correspondence: Mohame d Toukabri (toukabri200 0mohamed@gm ail.com)
Received: 24 December 2023 | Revised: 1 July 202 4 | Accepted: 1 July 202 4
Funding: The authors received no speci fic funding for thi s work.
Keywords: FinTech | growth | l iquidity | performance | r egulatory sandboxes | r isk
ABS TRAC T
The growth of FinTech has increa singly attracted the att ention of financial industry players. T he speed and complexity with
which new financial technologies have spre ad around the world have created regulator y challenges for the United States and
Canadian authorities. Unlike t he United States, where there is regulator y fragmentation and a superv isory instrument with
regulatory relief, Ca nada has a more integrated regulatory approach ma naged by regulatory sandbox principles. The ai m of this
article is to study and compare the impact of FinTech adoption on commercial bank s over the 2018– 2023 period in the United
States and Canadia n FinTech ecosystems. The results essential ly show that FinTech has a positive impact on commercial banks'
performance and fin ancial growth, a nd a negative impact on liquidity and financia l risk. Our results pre sent several contri-
butions and mainly show that: (1) In the presence of multiple entry channels for FinTech startups, the i mpact of FinTech on
financial perfor mance is higher in the United States than in Can ada. (2) Because of its regulatory approach, Canada lag s behind
the United States in the adoption rate of financi al technologies. (3) Balance of power in the fi nancial sector induces commercial
banks not to consider FinTech startups as t hreats but rather as partners that offer opportunities for ex pertise and reduced regu-
latory costs. Fi nally, FinTech can be disruptive and pres ents many challenges for regul ators given the complexity and speed of
innovation it promot es.
1 | Introduction
The global financia l landscape is currently undergoing a pro -
found transformation driven by t he rise of financial technology,
commonly refer red to as FinTech. T his transfor mative phenom-
enon covers novel bu siness par adigms, innovative t echnologi-
cal applications, and the introduction of new fin ancial products
and services, a ll exerting a substantial ef fect on financial mar-
kets (Breidbach, Keating, and Lim 2019; Zveryakov et al.2019;
Barroso and Laborda2 022).
The Financial Stabil ity Board (FSB) has succinctly def ined
FinTech as “financial in novation facilitated by technology,
which has the potential to give ris e to new business models,
applications, processes, or products c apable of significantly i m-
pacting financia l markets, institutions, and the deliver y of fi-
nancial service s”.
As the FinTech sector continues to burgeon, it has sparked i n-
tense cur iosity among f inancial researchers , practitioners ,
and regulators regardi ng its potential effects on the tra ditional
© 2024 Wiley P eriodicals LL C.
610 Thunderbird International Business Review, 2024
banking sector. Notably, numerous studies have examined t he
ramifications of Fi nTech adoption on banking performance
(Zveryakov et al.2 019; Dong et al.2020; Tay and Mourad2020;
Nguyen, Tran, and Ho 2022), efficiency (R. Wang, Liu, and
Luo2021; Cao, C ook, and Kristal2022) and the overall stabilit y
of the banking industr y (Vučinić2020; Khai Nguyen and Cuong
Dang2022; Verma and Chaka rwart y2023). However, these in-
vestigation s have predomina ntly overlooked the v ital dimen sions
of the broader FinTech ecosystem and the regulator y framework
governing the banki ng sector. Consequently, there is a signifi-
cant gap in the literature pert aining to this crucial dimension.
The finance literatu re exploring the effect of FinTech on the tra-
ditional financial sec tor has presented diverse viewpoints. S ome
scholars hold the p erspectiv e that the promotion of financia l
technology y ields positive outcome s for commercial ban ks. They
contend that digital technologies play a pivotal role in enha ncing
the efficiency of serv ices offered by banks and other f inancial
institutions, with a concerted ef fort to curtail operat ional ex-
penses. This, i n turn, bolsters their efficiency and opti mizes user
experience, enabling them to reach a broader spect rum of con-
sumers (Kalai et al. 202 4; Zhang et al.2023; Yao and Song2023).
Conversely, other research endeavors assert that fi nancial tech-
nology exerts adverse effec ts on the banking sector. Thes e ad-
verse impacts include heightened financial r isks, such as credit
risk (X. Wang et al. 2023) and liquidity risk (Fang et al. 2023).
Furthermore, it is posited that Fi nTech poses threats to the se-
curity of financia l transactions, potential ly facilitating ill icit
activities like money laundering and the f inancing of terrorism
(Thach et al. 2021; Vučinić and Luburić 2022), which in turn,
could precipitate a significa nt destabilization of financial ma r-
kets (Yudaruddi n et al. 20 23). Furthermore, as the financial
market relentlessly pursues innovation, FinTech products and
transactions have grow n increasingly intricate, rendering crisis
mitigation ch allenging.
Some scholars c ontend that FinTech 's impact on the f inancial
sector may be dual- edged. Y. Wang, Xiuping, and Zhang(2021)
pointed out that, in the short term, FinTech can help commer-
cial banks in acc umulating deposits and enhancing liquid ity.
However, as time progresses, tr aditional commercial banks may
grapple with escalating c osts attributed to mounting bad debts.
Contrarily, Zhang et al. (2023) argue that the financial r isks in-
curred by commercial ban ks due to FinTech outweigh the ben-
efits it brings.
Concerning the regulator y landscape, the rapid proliferation
of FinTech poses a multitude of challenges and intricacies for
regulatory bod ies. The expeditious and intricate d issemination
of novel financial technologies worldwide has pre sented regula-
tory hurdles for authorities (Podkolzina 2021). FinTech carries
numerous potential threats and risk s that must be effectively
managed to avert the possibi lity of destabilizing the f inancial
system. Additionally, the lessons draw n from various fina ncial
crises, including the pandemic, ca st doubt on the notion of self-
regulation within markets a nd underscore the inevitability of
intervention by regulatory b odies.
Within this context, reg ulators grapple with intricate i mpera-
tives that require reconci liation. On the one hand, they aspire
to adapt the conventional legal framework to accom modate the
nuances of emerging financia l technologies, thereby fostering
intensified competition within t he realm of financial ser vices.
Conversely, regulators also seek to overse e these potentially haz-
ardous activities, safeg uard consumers, and combat fraudulent
practices (Fenwick and Vermeulen2020).
This raises a pivota l inquiry: does the adoption of FinTech
within a specif ic regulatory fra mework governing the banking
sector have discernible effe cts on commercial banks in terms of
growth, perfor mance, financial risk, or liquidity ?
Our study examines the reg ulatory frameworks go verning the
FinTech landscapes in both Cana da and the United States,
aiming to elucidate their implications for commercial ba nks.
Although these two nations sha re resemblances in their FinTech
ecosystems, they ex hibit notable disparities in their regulat ory
approaches.
Comparatively, the financial regu latory system in the United
States is considerably more intricate than t hat of Canada. It in-
cludes a larger number of supervisory ag encies, leading to regu-
latory fragmentation acro ss various market segments. Financial
oversight in the United States is charac terized by stringent rules
and regulations. Nevertheless , it is worth noting that the US
system includes several state chart ers that serve as gateways for
new FinTech firms to enter the banki ng arena. These chart ers
offer the advantage of establ ishing a banking regulatory f rame-
work conducive to fostering innovation in the real m of financial
technology (Kowalski et a l.2023).
Canada has instituted a r egulatory frame work rooted in the
principles of a regulatory sandbox for f inancial technologies.
This regulator y sandbox is delineated as a meticulously con-
trolled domain wherein FinTech firms c an assess their in-
novation while being overseen by regu latory authorities. It
provides these companies with a favorable envi ronment that
exempts them from specific regu latory requirements. The
sandbox's distinct advantag e lies in its capacity to curt ail the
cost and durat ion associa ted with lau nching technolog ical
innovations and streaml ining the adoption of cutting- edge f i-
nancial te chnologies.
Nevertheless, it is essential to acknowledg e that factors such as
the stability of Canada's bank ing system and the higher con-
centration of the financial ser vices sector in compari son to the
United States may present challenges to innovat ion within the
sphere of financial technologies (Ozdemir2022).
This paper proposes to study the impac t of FinTech on commer-
cial banks in Ca nada and the United States and offers sev eral
contributions:
1. From a theoretical point of v iew, a bibliometric analysis ena-
bles us to study the impact of FinTech on traditional banks i n
the financial sect or, and to focus on the main studies carried
out over the last 5 years, thus providing a suitable framework
for analyzing FinTech and its implications for the ban king
sector. Our paper allows for deepening t he study of FinTech
and to emphasize and interpret the dif ferent pressures ex-
erted by FinTech on the banking sec tor, thus providing an
611
analytical f ramework conducive to the reforms of commer-
cial banks.
2. From an empirica l point of view, it compares the impact
of the FinTech index on the financial performa nce, risk,
growth, and liquidity of c ommercial banks in the United
States and Canada, u sing a static panel model and a dynamic
panel model. The results highlig ht the impact of different
FinTech ecosystems on the determina nts of commercial
banks.
3. From a regulatory per spective, it serves to emphasiz e
that policymakers are r equired to be aware of the risk s of
FinTech both when it is adopted internally by fina ncial in-
stitutions under r egulator y supervi sion and when it comes
from new market entrants in direct c ontact with consum-
ers. Regulators need to ensu re that regulatory ef forts are
coordinated in an increa singly complex financial ma rket.
Our study also shows that f rameworks based on regulatory
sandbox principles are not a panacea to evolvi ng financial
systems. Indeed, the concentrat ion of the Canadian bank-
ing sector is a constraint th at makes schemes based on these
principles less effective and slow to keep pace w ith interna-
tional FinTech i nnovation.
Our article is structu red as follows: Section 2 review s the liter-
ature. Sections 2 and 3 i ntroduces the re search metho dology.
Section 4 presents the main empirical resu lts. Section 5 def ines
the main practical and theoretic al implications of FinTech.
Finally, Section 6 concludes t he article.
2 | Literature Review and Conceptual Framework
Recognizing the pivot al role of banks within the f inancial sys-
tem underscores the imperative of comprehending the oppor-
tunities and challenges engendered by FinTech for commercial
banks and its broader impact on the fin ancial ecosystem. In
this study, we first used the Bibliometri x R- package softwa re,
which provides a set of tools for conducting quantitative biblio-
metric research (see AppendixA). It contains key algorith ms for
performing statist ical and scientific mapping analy ses. We aim
to exami ne the predomina nt themes concer ning FinTech a nd
the banking syst em to determine the trend of research topics in
this field by performi ng a co- occur rence network analysis. T he
table in Appendix A represents a chronological analysis of the
keywords of the main works cited ac cording to Web of Science
over the last 5 years, while Fig ure1 illustrates a co- occurrence
network representing a thematic analysis of t he principal
keywords .
A corpus of research suggest s that financial tech nology yields
favorable outcomes for commercial banks. The incept ion of in-
novative products and servic es serves as a catalyst for enhanced
financial perfor mance. Notably, banks harness Fi nTech offer-
ings to provide their clientele with online ser vices, simplif ying
access to a wide arr ay of financial services and enhanci ng over-
all user experience (Saif et al. 2022; Katsiampa et al.2022; Al-
Okaily et al.2023; Utami and Supria di2023).
Additional research has undersc ored the role of FinTech de-
velopment in bolstering the competitive edge of commercial
banks. Digital t echnologies assume a pivotal role in enhanc-
ing the efficiency of serv ices offered by banks t o small and
micro- enter prises whi le concurrentl y promoting fi nancial in -
clusion (Kandpal and Mehrotra 2019; Baber2020; Knaack and
Gruin2021; Apostu et al.2023; Yoon, Lee, and Oh2023).
Various technolog ical adva ncements, includi ng blockchain ap -
plications, novel digital adv isory and trading systems, arti ficial
intelligence (AI), peer- to- peer lending platforms, and mobile
payment systems, empower banks to c urtail customer acquisi-
tion expenses and institute more robust risk m anagement pro-
tocols (Daud et al.2022; Zhang et al .2023; X. Wang et al.2023).
This, in tur n, leads to substantial reductions in resource misal-
location attributed to credit corr uption and contributes to the
optimization of investment efficiency (Wu et al . 2020; Ileberi
et al.2021; Peng et al.2023).
Furthermore, as posited by Tay a nd Mourad (2020), FinTech
products have the potential to temper banks' ri sk- taking
FIGURE | Co- occurrence network: FinTech and the ba nking sector. [Color figure ca n be viewed at wileyonl inelibrary.com]
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations