A model for predicting creative accounting in emerging economies

• Date: 16 September 2024
• Pages: 1-31
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/IJAIM-09-2023-0240
• Published date: 16 September 2024
• Author: Ghassem Blue,Masoumeh Chahrdahcheriki,Zabihollah Rezaee,Mohsen Khotanlou

A model for predicting creative

accounting in emerging economies

Ghassem Blue and Masoumeh Chahrdahcheriki

Department of Accounting, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran

Zabihollah Rezaee

Crews School of Accountancy, University of Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee, USA, and

Mohsen Khotanlou

Department of Accounting, Faculty of Economics and Social Science,

Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

Abstract

Purpose –This study aims to present a modelfor detecting and predicting creative accounting in companies

listed on the TehranStock Exchange (TSE).

Design/methodology/approach –The authors conduct this research in three stages. First, the authors review

the literature to determine the dimensions, components, indicators and techniques of creative accounting. Second,

the authors conduct semi-structured interviews with experts using the fuzzy Delphi technique to obtain screening

and reach a consensus. Finally, the authors develop a model to predict creative accounting by classifying the

f‌inancial statements of the sample companies into two groups based on the use or non-use of creative accounting

techniques, measuring the indicators determined in the previous stage, running various machine learning

algorithms and choosing the superior algorithm.

Findings –The results indicate the usefulness ofaccounting information for detecting and predicting creative

accounting and the relevance of several f‌inancial attributes as important predictors. The results also indicate the

superiority of extremely randomized trees over other algorithmsin predicting creative accounting and suggest that

the primary purpose of creative accounting in Iran is earnings management. Contrary to the political cost

hypothesis, large Iraniancompanies use creative accounting to inf‌late prof‌its.

Research limitations/implications –The present research also has several limitations that must be considered,

and caution must be exercised in interpreting and generalizing the f‌indings as specif‌ied in the revised manuscript.

Practical implications –This study’s implications are signif‌icant for policymakers, standard-setters and

practitioners. By recognizing the detrimental effects of creative accounting on f‌inancial transparency within

companies, policymakers can address existing gaps in accounting standards to minimize the potential for earnings

manipulation. Consequently, strengthening internal and external mechanisms related to a f‌irm’sf‌inancial

performance becomes achievable. The study provides evidence of the need for audit f‌irms to recognize the

importance of creative accounting and consider creative accounting in their audit plans to prevent insuff‌icient or

even misleading disclosure by companies that extensively use creative accounting practices in their f‌inancial

reporting. Moreover, knowledge of creative accounting techniques can help auditors assess audit and detection

risks and serve as a valuable guide for reducing audit costs and improving audit quality.

Social implications –Given that creative accounting practices distort the true or real accounting results,

curbing creative accounting practicesreduces corporate failures and could lead to the reduction of job losses

and other social consequences.

Originality/value –This study uses a unique database in Iranto determine a model for predicting creative

accounting using a mixed-method methodology, qualitative and quantitative, to identify creative accounting

techniquesand run various machine learning algorithms.

Keywords Creative accounting, Machine learning, Extremely randomized trees (ET) algorithm,

Predictive model

Paper type Research paper

International

Journal of

Accounting &

Information

Management

1

Received28 September 2023

Revised25 May 2024

Accepted27 August 2024

InternationalJournal of

Accounting& Information

Management

Vol.33 No. 1, 2025

pp. 1-31

© Emerald Publishing Limited

1834-7649

DOI 10.1108/IJAIM-09-2023-0240

The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:

https://www.emerald.com/insight/1834-7649.htm

1. Introduction

Financial reports are intended to communicate corporate performance, f‌inancial positions

and management accountability to stakeholders, including shareholders. The accuracy,

reliability and transparency of f‌inancial reports can be adversely affected by creative

accounting practices within the bounds of accounting regulations and standards to presenta

more favorable picture of a company’sf‌inancial position [1]. Therefore, decision-making

processes can be inf‌luenced by biased f‌inancial statements, which pose risks to the integrity

of f‌inancial reports (Teixeira and Rodrigues, 2022) and undermine investors’capacity to

accurately evaluate the company’s actual value (Bhasin, 2016). Despite the measures taken

by regulators to prevent the use of creative accounting, f‌inancial scandals related to these

practices have been increasing worldwide, which results in the loss of investor conf‌idence

and public trust in f‌inancial markets and the potential bankruptcy of many companies

(Hussein et al., 2015;Rezaee and Riley, 2009). Creative accounting has gained substantial

attention because of intensifying competition among companies globally, the need to

enhance f‌inancial reporting quality, rapid technological advancements, the complexities of

the economic environment, the emergence of new f‌inancial instruments and unfair

competition (Preda et al.,2022). The f‌inancial crises heightened market depth, and

hyperinf‌lation in Iran has compelled investors to turn toward the capital market, amplifying

the demand for transparent and dependableinformation (Roudari et al., 2023). Knowledge of

the use of creative accounting techniques by companies can improve investor decisions and

increase users’trust in the f‌inancial reporting system. We present a model for detecting and

predicting creative accounting in companies listed on the Tehran Stock Exchange (TSE) to

foster a culture of integrity and ethical behavior within organizations to prevent the

temptation to engage in deceptivecreative accounting practices.

The Iran setting provides a unique opportunity to examine creative accounting practices

and their determinantsand consequences because the Iranian economy has been signif‌icantly

impacted by economic sanctions at both micro and macro levels, which have triggered

signif‌icant f‌luctuations in the stockmarket index (Blue et al.,2023). Sanctions have also led

to reduced eff‌iciency,import/export diff‌iculties, higher pricesof raw materials, higher cost of

production and, consequently, poor performance. In response to these conditions, managers

may engage in opportunistic f‌inancial reportingbehaviors to present a more favorable image

of their company’sf‌inancial position and performance, which has eroded investors’trust in

f‌inancial reports (Arabi et al., 2017). Furthermore, MohammadRezaei et al. (2017) f‌ind that

f‌inancial distress and declining prof‌itability resulting from sanctions have led to a surge in

earnings management in Iran through hiding or underreporting income and assets and

making f‌inancial manipulation an enticing option for reducing tax liabilities and avoiding

regulatory scrutiny. Creative accounting remains a signif‌icant challenge in Iran despite the

regulatory measures taken to combat these practices, which can reduce the reliability and

relevance of f‌inancial reports and affect the stability of businesses (Kallantary et al.,2024).

Motivated by prior studies relevant to creativeaccounting and the unique Iranian setting, we

examine creative accounting in Iran and seek to provide a model for predicting creative

accounting by addressingour research questions:

RQ1. What are the key indicatorsand techniques for creative accounting in Iran?

RQ2. How can a model be developedfor predictive creative accounting in Iran?

We conduct our research in three stages. First, we review the literature to determine the

dimensions, components, indicators and techniques of creative accounting. Second, we

conduct semi-structured interviews with experts using the fuzzy Delphi technique to obtain

IJAIM

33,1

2