Report No. 92 (2019) IACHR. Case No. 11.624 (Ecuador)

Case Number11.624
Year2019
Report Number92
Respondent StateEcuador
Case TypeMerits
CourtInter-American Comission of Human Rights
Alleged VictimJorge Darwin García y familia
REPORT No. 92/19
CASE 11.624
REPORT ON ADMISIBILITY AND MERITS (PUBLICATION)
JORGE DARWIN GARCÍA AND FAMILY
ECUADOR
Approved electronically by the C.n on J. 14, 2019.
OEA/Ser.L/V/II.
D.. 101
J. 14, 2019
Original: Spanish
Cite as: IACHR, R. No. 92/19 , C. 11.624, Admissibility and M.ts, J.D..G.ía
and family, Ecuador, J. 14, 2019.
www.cidh.org
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. SUMMARY ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 2
II. PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE IACHR ..................................................................................................................................... 2
III. POSITION OF THE PARTIES ...................................................................................................................................................... 3
A. Position of the petitioner .......................................................................................................................................... 3
B. Position of the S. .................................................................................................................................................... 4
IV. ANALYSIS ON ADMISSIBILITY ................................................................................................................................................. 6
A..J. of the C.n ratione temporis, ratione personae, ratione materiae y ratione
loci ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 6
B. Exhaustion of domestic remedies ......................................................................................................................... 6
C..D. for filing ........................................................................................................................................................ 7
D..D. of international proceedings and cosa juzgada ..................................................................... 7
E. Colorable claim ............................................................................................................................................................. 7
V. ANALYSIS OF THE MERITS ....................................................................................................................................................... 8
A..P. facts .................................................................................................................................................................... 8
1. R...J...D..G.cía and his family ............................................................................. 8
2. Regarding the death of J...D..G.ía and the injuries of F..P. ..... 9
3. Domestic proceedings related to the death of J...D. García .................................. 10
3.1. P. investigation ................................................................................................................................. 10
3.2. Criminal proceeding 208-93 ............................................................................................................... 12
B. Legal analysis ............................................................................................................................................................... 14
1. The rights to life and humane treatment (Articles 4 and 5 of the A.ican
Convention in relation to A.le 1.1 thereto) ............................................................................. 14
2. The rights to a fair trial and to judicial protection with respect to the investigations
and proceedings initiated on the death of J...D..G. (A.les 8 and 25 of
the A.ican Convention in relation to A.les 1.1 and 2 thereto) ................................. 15
VI. PROCEEDINGS SUBSEQUENT TO REPORT No.42/15 ................................................................................................. 21
VII. PROCEEDINGS AFTER REPORT No. 69/18 ...................................................................................................................... 21
VIII. ANALYSIS ON COMPLIANCE WITH THE RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................ 22
IX. FINAL CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ....................................................................................................... 22
X. PUBLICATION ................................................................................................................................................................................ 23

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT