The Gift that Keeps on Giving - Distribution and Copyleft in Open Source Software License
| Author | Heather Meeker |
| Position | Partner, Greenberg Traurig, LLP |
| Pages | 29-40 |
!∀#∃%&∃∋∋(%)#%∗∗
+,
−.−/01/0
23%%.
20/
%
444
05!6%7%60
0.0%
8%
!# #.93,%,.0
. + %3
:; 0. . + .
20+.,0%
. ,8 + / +
++. 20 ,
0 0+%
0 +. 0 0 ,%
2 :;
20 ,% 3 0 0 ,
.. %0
. . /
0/ , 0 % 00
!67 =%).!#
∋∃
2.2%
, . %
. .
% !3 . :00;
% . 3 . 2
%
,∋.,∋. ∃∃>.0
.:;: %;
3+ . , 0
20%,0 /
+. 2 ,
%
.03%%.
5 ? #> 3 ≅% #>
/ :
%;# 5 :
%; % Α Β 0
0 . + Β
% # >∗ Χ 7∋ :;.
:; . : !
∀ # ∃ ∀
%;)2%&
#∃∗?∋≅ 5 / :
%; , .
/ .. 000 +% ∗5
. :;: #
%& ∋(∋%;> . . /
+Β%
! 3 . . 0 %
# #>3%%%#∃∗?∋≅%
#>3%%%#∃#%
∋ Χ%7%7%9% )8#)>∗%
) ∀((%((#%0%
&)∗+,+#+−.+.)>#3%%&∋ .&&?# ∆&≅%
∗−/∗0+,+#+/ 1+,2,+. #6%)∗.)∋∃?∆%# ∋≅%
>∗+0+∗+.%# %
!67 =%).!#
∋#
2 2∀
1
+ 0 0 : ;
:; 5% ! :
.; :0; :
.;%∆
!. :; 0 ?#≅0. ?≅
0 . ?∋≅ : . . %;
5 0+ .:
+
%; .
+.
...+%
! 0 0 . 0
%! 0+
2 , 000 8
8 , 0% . 0
%Α. .
0 %0
0 + , 0
00. 0
% Ε.
.00+.0%
0 + 0 0 00
5,550.0%
Α 0 .
0 3%% ,%5
20 .
00 020% 00 :5,
%;#∃
∆3#+4 )6%%&∃.&∃&?%%%# &∃≅45/0+,+#+60)1,%.∗∆6%#∃∋∆.
#∃)8)∋?>%# ∆∃≅?:Φ0Β;≅4
6+5,+#+37/+,+.∋6%∋∗.∋∗?#%∃∃∋≅48#+>#)6%
#∃∆∆.#∃ #?##%# ∆∋≅43 1+ /+#+)∋∃6%%)&∆.)>∃?Γ%%,%∃∃∗≅4+
1#,+#+8,/ 2,+∋>∆6%%##∆ .## ∆?%%%∃∃&≅489+0+1+
,+#+−//:.#+.∆∆6%%&)).&&&?%%9%Η%∃∃∋≅%
Χ%7%7%9% )8#)>∗.#∋∆?# >∗≅%
#∃ 070.0%Ι%0
+.00%∀((%+%(%1
!67 =%).!#
∋
,∋. % 5.
,∋
20% 30. 0 0 ,∋
00 0 +:5 ,%;0
,∋ 0+ 5, 55 20% ! ,∋.
:;. :%#&
#+
#%;
33. 2 . 0%.
3.55
20%##
?
≅550?≅.0
00 .
%
%Α 0 . %
+ : ;
20% Χ. . :
.;0
% . 0
040
. % 6 00
:%;
0
0%Γ00
? 00/≅
0%
04 .
0.
% , .
0%
0 0
0. %
+ 0.
00 0%!
0 0 0 0.
0%Χ.00
ϑ∃∃>∃)∃∋##)#&>#∃
## !5500.000%.055
0.002055%Χ.
/.0Κ.0%0
Λ20%
!67 =%).!#
∋∋
. 0
. % 0 +.
.
0 Β% 0.
.0%
0
0 %
0.0.
00%Χ.0
0 :; + 20
0% ! .!0 0
0+ 0 0
0Β % 0 0 .
. 3%% 0%
00+ 0 :;
,%
0
. / .
.
%6/0.00/+.
0 . 8 %! 0
0 + Γ
% 6 /. . . 0 0
Γ %!
8 0. 0 0
..:;
0.+%0
0Λ8 .
/ %# Ε 08
. 0 0
+%200.0
08 . + !
. 0
%
! 3%% 2+ 8
Λ 0 0
2%50?≅
%..
0 . 0 0
0 %
3%% .#∋
Λ % . 8/
# !.20,+.
0Λ8.00400+2%
#∋ +.0.+
20%70?≅.∋#>%
!67 =%).!#
∋)
%#) . + 8
/ .
0 / % 0+ 0 0
0. 2
0
0 % Γ 0
2. 0 / %
0 0 % !
0 . 0
.
%0..
00ΙΜ5 0.
+,%
∀#50/0 .
2 00 0
0 % 0
55
, 0% 0 +
5, 20 % Χ.
% 6 00
.
%50550..
0 0+ ?
≅. 55
0Β0.0Β%0
0%60
. 55 % Ε .
0 +%!0Β
0 0
/ 550. 00 0
0 0 0/ ,
8, 0 . + +
0%
Α 0. / 0 ,.
0%
∃∃%
,65Ν.066?66≅66Β
20%6/0.
#) 6.,+,#+#+,+/+.& >6%#∃ ∃?∗%# > ≅%6.
%%0;0,+#+# #3%%%ΓΟ!#∃ >?9%%%# #≅%
0Β#+∗#
//+#∆,%#∆?%# )>≅%
!67 =%).!#
∋&
65Ν2∀
− = ! + 1
> = # #
# #
#+
# = =
#+ ,#
7+∋?
65Ν
3 # 22
!+
# + 90
+
, #
+
≅ 2
+∋Α
! 65Ν. 66 + . 3 . 0
0Λ8 0 % 6. 66
0
%
, 65Ν 0 ,
80∀
! ∀
Β+ : #
+
7#−51+
#& ∀((%%((8(8%∃82%0Π!?0≅%065Ν
,∋65Ν%?∀((%%((82%0Π!%≅
#∗ ∀((%%((8(8%∃82%0Π?0≅%065Ν
,∋65Ν%?∀((%%((82%0Π%≅
!67 =%).!#
∋∗
Β
+ , 7
#−51+
# #+,
∃#+∋Χ
Ι0265Ν%!
65Ν.66 ∀ ?#≅ 0
?≅ 0
,. 0 0
%3.65Ν: 0;
0 Β , . , 0
0 . 0 % .
.24,
,0 . ?≅
,. % ! 65Ν 0 .
0. .
,%
0 0 66 65Ν 0
% Ε . .0 00 ∀ 0
0, . 0% ! / 0
% 00 . 2
%Ε 00 %.
20.
0+%
66Β 0 %6. 0∀ 0
0 Β 8
0% / 0, 0
%Ε66Β /.
%. 0∀ 00 +
:00ΘΡ 0 0
. . . ;?%%
≅00%.
0%
%
! 0 + 0 :; 2
2 3 % Ε , .
#> ∀((%%((8(8%∃82%0Π395%065Ν
,∋65Ν%?∀((%%((82%0Π395%≅
!67 =%).!#
∋>
. % 5
. 0+ 2 3%%
Ε , 5 Α+. #∆ 0 Α!,
. :0+ ; +. 0
3 Β . 0 0. 55
%. . 3%%.0
3%%
&∀∋∋
5 00 . 0
Β .
00
2% 9
0. 0 0. .
+%
∋
0 .
0∀
( ) ∗ :/
# # >
/ +; .
.
%
:/
# # /
/ 0 #
+; 66 65Ν
%
0 0
:+ 0 ; 0 0. 0
0 0 + :+ 0 ;.
//−∆#+∗+∋Ε
#∆ ∀((%%(#>( %0
# / /#−7∆#+∗) ∃3%%>∋∃0+
+0?0≅?0.≅..
0.+2+.+.
+.0./Β
+.+0
%.00+0.
0%
!67 =%).!#
∋∆
!
+∀( , . 0
0 +.
0 0 %
0
.0%!
. .
% .
/ 0. 0 .
Β0%Χ.0
0 .0
,%0
.%.
0 0. Β
. 0
, % 5 0
0,%
0
0 55 0 0
0% 00.
.5500+
% 5 2
+0 Β .0 0.
550+
%
,!0.
0 .0 0
00 0 0% 0
0..0
. / 0
00 0 0/ .
% !
0%
∀##
2 0 + 0 3 %
0 2%
?
+, ≅. 0
!67 =%).!#
∋
% 5. 0 , 0
+ 0 0 0 2. 0
% ! ,
.0
0+%!0+2
, 0 . / +.
0% 0 0
0 + 2.
.0
0%
#∃,Φ,
=
+01#0
/!1 ,Γ(∋∋56
Γ?/+
1#Η9∗#
:Γ((Ι+
!67 =%).!#
)∃
!67 =%).!#
Licence and Attribution
This paper was published in the International Free and Open Source Software Law
Review, Volume 4, Issue 1 (March 2012). It originally appeared online at
http://www.ifosslr.org.
This article should be cited as follows:
Meeker, Heather (2012) 'The Gift that Keeps on Giving – Distribution and Copyleft in
Open Source Software Licenses', IFOSS L. Rev., 4(1), pp 29-40
DOI: 10.5033/ifosslr.v4i1.66
Copyright © 2012 Heather Meeker
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons UK (England and Wales) 2.0
licence, no derivative works, attribution, CC-BY-ND
∀((00%((8(%∃(+(
As a special exception, the author expressly permits faithful translations of the entire
document into any language, provided that the resulting translation (which may
include an attribution to the translator) is shared alike. This paragraph is part of the
paper, and must be included when copying or translating the paper.
