Derecho al Debido Proceso

AuthorCentro de Derechos Humanos
Pages9-11
#6)∗∀!&!+.%∗∋∗(∋∗=&%∃!++#%/∗ΧΑ∀#+#∋(
6)∗∀!&!+.%∗∋(∗∀!?#∀%∗=&%+!,%
)
.0Μ0/(%0∀(Ν∗2#%∋(%0(&3∆0∗2&Χ#/(∀#∗(%0∗#6#/&1&∋30∗(>∋/Γ#%#∗(%0((
>∋/5#(&3%0603%&0320(%0(∀#(6/0∗032#1&Ε3(%0(#11&∋30∗(1&∆&∀0∗(
Σ8#ϑ6()%∋(6−∃∀7)8#−∃#28# ςΒ>#=8#%)−,#7,∀%&8∀&∃#∃∀#%∃Μ828(#Κ6∃1#∃∀#78%,%#−∃#−∃%8∋8()7)Φ∀#Χ,(Γ8−81#∃2#−∃(∃7=,#
)∀&∃(∀87),∀82#?#∃2#−∃Α∃(#;∃∀∃(82#−∃#;8(8∀&48#)∗∋,∀∃∀#28#,Α2);87)Φ∀#−∃#)∀Ε∃%&);8(#∃2#78%,#gz"qekq1#%)∀#−)287)Φ∀1#?#−∃#6∀8#∗8∀∃(8#
%∃()81#)∗∋8(7)82#?#∃Χ∃7&)Ε81#−∃#∗,−,#&82#Κ6∃#∀,#−∃∋∃∀−8#−∃#28#)∀)7)8&)Ε8#∋(,7∃%82#−∃#28#Ε47&)∗8#,#−∃#%6%#Χ8∗)2)8(∃%#φ∃∀#∋8(&)7628(1#
−∃#28#∋(∃%∃∀&87)Φ∀#−∃#6∀8#−∃∀6∀7)8γ#,#−∃#28#8∋,(&87)Φ∀#∋()Ε8−8#−∃#∃2∃∗∃∀&,%#∋(,Α8&,(),%.[
!∀#∃2#78%,#Ι∋3Γϑ∀0Γ( Κ0%&3##Λ( >#5&∀/0∗Π( nc" Eqtvg" cÝtoc" swg" guvg" fgdgt" fg" kpxguvkicek„p" gu" kpfgrgpfkgpvg" fg" nc"
∋(∃%∃∀&87)Φ∀#−∃#6∀8#877)Φ∀#7)Ε)2#∋,(#∋8(&∃#−∃#28#Ε47&)∗8#,#%6%#Χ8∗)2)8(∃%#∋,(#2,#7682#8∗∋2)8#28#8∋2)787)Φ∀#−∃#∃%&∃#∋()∀7)∋),#8#28#
∋(∃%∃∀&87)Φ∀#−∃#877),∀∃%#∋∃∀82∃%#,#7)Ε)2∃%Ψ#
Ωαβχ#α!χ0#∋&Ι/%#∃&Ε∋&∃0#∋,(∃.!1/&7−∃&(/0&.#!4∋0&∀/&∃0#:∀&/,(!≅∋1/0&∋&!∀#∃%3/∀∃%&
%∃.−%0/0&!∀#∃%∀/0&7−∃&∀/&0∃∋∀&∋1∃.−∋1/0&3∋%∋&1∃#∃%4!∀∋%&∃(&3∋%∋1∃%/&1∃&(∋&3∃%0/∀∋&1∃0∋3∋%∃.!1∋5&∃0.(∋%∃.∃%&(/0&
Ε∃.Ε/0&?&∃0#∋,(∃.∃%&(∋0&%∃03/∀0∋,!(!1∋1∃0&!∀1!6!1−∋(∃0&1∃%!6∋1∋0&1∃&∃((/05&(/&.−∋(&∃0&∋3(!.∋,(∃&∋(&∃Γ∃%.!.!/&1∃&−∀∋&
∋..!=∀&.!6!(&3∋%∋&1∃.(∋%∋%&∋&∋(≅−!∃∀&./4/&)3∃%0/∀∋&1∃0∋3∋%∃.!1∋ΦΒ&ϑ∋&Ι/%#∃&./∀0!1∃%∋&7−∃&∃(&Ε∋,∃%&0−3∃1!#∋1/&(∋&
!43−#∋,!(!1∋1&1∃&%∃03/∀0∋,!(!1∋1∃0&3∃∀∋(∃0&∋&(∋&3%∃6!∋&!∀#∃%3/0!.!=∀&1∃&−∀∋&∋..!=∀&.!6!(&7−∃&1∃.(∋%∋%∋&∋(&0∃8/%&
9/∀2:(∃2& ;∃1!∀∋& ./4/& Π3∃%0/∀∋& 1∃0∋3∋%∃.!1∋Θ& ./∀0#!#−?=& −∀& /,0#:.−(/& 3∋%∋& (∋& !∀6∃0#!≅∋.!=∀& ∃
0−.∃1!1/&?&(∋&1∃#∃%4!∀∋.!=∀&?&0∋∀.!=∀&1∃&(/0&%∃03/∀0∋,(∃0ΦΒ&φ!#∗∋(Ι∋3Γϑ∀0Γ(Κ0%&3##Λ(>#5&∀/0∗1(∋9((∆#..∴γ
.0/01+∋(%0(∀∋∗(>#5&∀/0∗(%0(∀#(∆Φ12&5#(#(#110%0/(#∀(0_60%&0320(%0(∀#(&3∆0∗2&Χ#1&Ε3
Σ8# ςΒ>#=8#∃%&8Α2∃7)−,#Κ6∃#∃2#877∃%,#82#∃Λ∋∃−)∃∀&∃#∃%#6∀#(∃Κ6)%)&,#0!∀∃&7−∋&∀/∀#−∃#28#)∀&∃(Ε∃∀7)Φ∀#∋(,7∃%82#−∃#
28#Ε)7&)∗8#,#−∃#%6%#Χ8∗)2)8(∃%#∃∀#28#Κ6∃#%∃#7,∀%&)&6?∃∀#7,∗,#∋8(&∃#7,8−?6Ε8∀&∃#,#Κ6∃(∃228∀&∃1#%∃;+∀#28#2∃;)%287)Φ∀#)∀&∃(∀8_/∆#
Σ8#∋8(&)7)∋87)Φ∀#∋2∃∀8#∃∀#∃2#∋(,7∃%,#∋,(#∋8(&∃#−∃#28#Ε)7&)∗8#%∃#Ε∃(48#Ε62∀∃(8−8#7,∀#28#∀∃;87)Φ∀#−∃#∃%&8#;8(8∀&48#ϑ6−)7)82∆#Θ)#
Α)∃∀#28#ςΒ>#∃∀#%6#ϑ6()%∋(6−∃∀7)8#(∃7)∃∀&∃_0#=8#7,∀%)−∃(8−,#8−∗)%)Α2∃#28#(∃%∃(Ε8#−∃#28%#−)2);∃∀7)8%#8−∃28∀&8−8%#−6(8∀&∃#
nc"kpxguvkicek„p"rtgnkokpct"gp"gn"rtqeguq"rgpcn"rctc"nc"gÝecekc"fg"nc"cfokpkuvtcek„p"fg"lwuvkekc."gu"rtgekuq"fgekt."swg"c"tgin„p"
%∃;6)−,#28##=8#(∃78278−,#Κ6∃Ψ
Ωαβχ# α!χ∀& ∀!∀≅Η∀& .∋0/& (∋& %∃0∃%6∋& 3−∃1∃& !∀6/.∋%0∃& 3∋%∋& !43∃1!%& ∋& (∋& 6>.#!4∋& ∃(& ∋..∃0/& ∋(& ∃∆3∃1!∃∀#∃& 1∃&
−∀∋&.∋−0∋&3∃∀∋(Β&ϑ∋&3/#∃0#∋1&1∃(&∗0#∋1/&1∃&∃6!#∋%&(∋&1! 1∃(&./∀#∃∀!1/&1∃(&3%/.∃0/5&1∃&0∃%&∃(&.∋0/5&1∃,∃&0∃%&
≅∋%∋∀#!2∋1∋& ∋1/3#∋∀1/& (∋0& 4∃1!1∋0& ∀∃.∃0∋%!∋0& ./43∋#!,(∃0& ./∀& ∃(& ∃Γ∃%.!.!/&1∃& (/0& 1∃%∃.Ε/0& 3%/.∃0∋(∃0& 1∃& (∋0&
6>.#!4∋0Ξ∆#φ!#∗∋(Ι∋3Γϑ∀0Γ(Κ0%&3##Λ(>#5&∀/0∗1#∋9((&.⊥_γ
Rqt"vcpvq."nc"tgugtxc"cfokukdng"c"nc"swg"ug"tgÝgtg"nc"Eqtvg"gp"tgncek„p"c"nc"rqvguvcf"guvcvcn"rctc"gxkvct"nc"fkhwuk„p"fgn"
7,∀&∃∀)−,#−∃2#∋(,7∃%,1#−∃Α∃#%∃(#;8(8∀&)Γ8−8#8−,∋&8∀−,#28%#∗∃−)−8%#∀∃7∃%8()8%#7,∗∋8&)Α2∃%#7,∀#∃2#∃ϑ∃(7)7),#−∃#2,%#−∃(∃7=,%#
∋(,7∃%82∃%#−∃#28%#Ε47&)∗8%_.∆#Σ8#Ε62∀∃(87)Φ∀#8#∃%&∃#8%∋∃7&,#−∃2#−∃Α)−,#∋(,7∃%,1#∃%#2,#,76(()−,#∃∀#∃2#78%,#Ι∋3Γ#∀0Γ(Κ0%&3#(Λ(
>#5&∀/0∗1(∃∀#∃2#7682#28#
Ωαβχ#α:χ(&(!4!#∋%&∃(&∋..∃0/&∋&(/0&
%∋2=∀&7−∃& 0−&.∋(!1∋1&1∃&6>.#!4∋05&∃(&∗0#∋1/&!∀.−43(!=&0−&/,(!≅∋.!=∀&1∃&%∃03∃#∋%(∃0&∃(&1∃%∃.Ε/&1∃&
3∋%#!.!3∋%&∃∀&∃(&3%/.∃0/Β&∗∀&./∀0∃.−∃∀.!∋5&∃(&+%!,−∀∋(&./∀0!1∃%∋&7−∃&(∋&Τ∃3Η,(!.∋&Υ/4!∀!.∋∀∋&6!/(=&∃(&1∃%∃.Ε/&1∃&
(/0& 1∃&3∋%#!.!3∋%&3(∃∀∋4∃∀#∃&∃∀&(∋&!∀6∃0#!≅∋.!=∀&3∃∀∋(&%∃(∋#!6∋&∋&(/0&Ε∃.Ε/0&
1∃(&3%∃0∃∀#∃&.∋0/&?5&3/%∋∀#/5&∃(&∋%#>.−(/&ςΒΛ&1∃&(∋&Ι/∀6∃∀.!=∀&Χ4∃%!.∋∀∋5&∃∀&%∃(∋.!=∀&./∀&∃(&∋%#>.−(/&ΛΒΛ&1∃(&4!04/&
!∀0#%−4∃∀#/Ξ∆#φ!#∗∋(Ι∋3Γϑ∀0Γ(Κ0%&3##Λ(>#5&∀/0∗1(∋9((∆#.⊥Ζγ
.0/01+∋(%0(∀∋∗(3&∋∗(Λ(3&#∗(#(∗0/(0∗1∃1+#%∋∗(Λ(#(Ψ∃0(∗0(203Χ#3(03(1∃032#(∗∃∗(∋6&3&∋30∗
Σ8##∃∀#%6#ϑ6()%∋(6−∃∀7)81#=8#(∃%82&8−,#Κ6∃#∀)Μ8%#?#∀)Μ,%#%,∀#%6ϑ∃&,%#∋2∃∀,%#−∃#−∃(∃7=,%1#8−∃∗9%#−∃#7,∀&8(#
7,∀#28%#∗∃−)−8%#∃%∋∃7)82∃%#−∃#∋(,&∃77)Φ∀#7,∀&∃∗∋28−8%#∃∀#∃2#8(&4762,#0[#−∃#28# :∗∃()78∀81#28%#7682∃%#−∃Α∃∀#%∃(#
fgÝpkfcu"ugi¿p"ncu"ektewpuvcpekcu"rctvkewnctgu"fg"ecfc"ecuq"eqpetgvq__∆#
Ι∀8#−∃#28%#;8(8∀&48%#ϑ6−)7)82∃%#−∃#2,%#∀)Μ,%#?#∀)Μ8%#∃%#∃2#−∃(∃7=,#−∃#%∃(#∃%767=8−,%#?#−∃#Κ6∃#%∃#&∃∀;8∀#∃∀#76∃∀&8#%6%#
,∋)∀),∀∃%1#28#7682#=8#%)−,#∃Λ∋(∃%8∗∃∀&∃#(∃7,∀,7)−8#∃∀#∃2#8(&4762,#0.#−∃#28#−∃2#Ρ)Μ,∆#:2#(∃%∋∃7&,#
∃2#−∃#2,%#Β∃(∃7=,%#−∃2#Ρ)Μ,#−∃#28%#Ρ87),∀∃%#Ι∀)−8%#=8#(∃78278−,#Κ6∃#∃2#−∃(∃7=,#8#Ω%∃(#∃%767=8−,#∃∀#&,−,#∋(,7∃−)∗)∃∀&,#
ϑ6−)7)82#,#8−∗)∀)%&(8&)Ε,#Κ6∃#8Χ∃7&∃#82#∀)Μ,Ξ#)∗∋2)78#Κ6∃#Ω∃%&8#−)%∋,%)7)Φ∀#∃%#8∋2)78Α2∃#8#&,−,%#2,%#∋(,7∃−)∗)∃∀&,%#ϑ6−)7)82∃%#
∋∃(&)∀∃∀&∃%#Κ6∃#8Χ∃7&∃∀#82#∀)Μ,1#%)∀#2)∗)&87),∀∃%Ξ
;=# <8%,#]∃29%Κ6∃Γ#≅,−(4;6∃Γ#Ε%∆#>,∀−6(8%1#0−3%∋#∀,&8#0Η#<8%,#Τ∃2∗8∀#Ε%∆#Ι(6;68?∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.Ζ#−∃#Χ∃Α(∃(,#−∃#./00∆#Θ∃()∃# 9((∆#0∴ηΗ#<8%,#Τ,∗∃%#Σ6∀−#?#
,&(,%#φΤ6∃(()2=8#−,#:(8;68)8γ#Ε%∆#3(8%)2∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.Ζ#−∃#∀,Ε)∃∗Α(∃#−∃#./0/∆#Θ∃()∃# ∋9((∆#0/∴Η#<8%,# Ε%∆#!2#Θ82Ε8−,(∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#_0#−∃#
8;,%&,#−∃#./00∆#Θ∃()∃#
" Ecuq"Iqp¦ƒng¦"Ogfkpc"{"Hcoknkctgu"xu0"Tgr¿dnkec"Fqokpkecpc."0−3%∋&pqvc"42."rƒtt0"475"{"ecuq"Tcfknnc"Rcejgeq"xu0"Of‌izkeq."0−3%∋#∀,&8#_1#∋9((∆#.⊥.∆#
" Ecuq"Dcttgvq"Ngkxc"xu0"Xgpg¦wgnc0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"39"fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"422;0"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"428."rƒtt0"67="Ecuq"Tcfknnc"Rcejgeq"xu0"Of‌izkeq."0−3%∋#∀,&8#_1#∋9((∆#.⊥.Η#<8%,#
Iqp¦ƒng¦"Ogfkpc"{"Hcoknkctgu"xu0"Tgr¿dnkec"Fqokpkecpc."0−3%∋&∀,&8#./1#∋9((∆#.⊥_∆
" Ecuq"Tcfknnc"Rcejgeq"xu0"Of‌izkeq."0−3%∋"pqvc"5."rƒtt0"474"{"Ecuq"Iqp¦ƒng¦"Ogfkpc"{"Hcoknkctgu"xu0"Tgr¿dnkec"Fqokpkecpc."0−3%∋#∀,&8#./1#∋9((∆#.⊥_∆
<<# Ψ#6∗8∀,%#−∃2#Ρ)Μ,∆#ι∋)∀)Φ∀#
0−3%∋"pqvc"4;."rƒtt0"343="Ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu"xu0"Ejkng."Ugpvgpekc"fg"46"fg"hgdtgtq"fg"42340"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"45;."rƒtt0"3;80
# Ρ87),∀∃%#Ι∀)−8%1#
!∗
!∀#∃2#78%,#Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu1#28#
Ω∗(%!,−∀∋(&/,0∃%6∋&7−∃&∃(&∋%#>.−(/&ςΒΛ&1∃&(∋&Ι/∀6∃∀.!=∀&Χ4∃%!.∋∀∋&./∀0∋≅%∋&∃(&1∃%∃.Ε/&∋&0∃%&/>1/&7−∃&
/0#∃∀#∋∀& #/1∋0& (∋0& 3∃%0/∀∋05& !∀.(−!1/0& (/0& ∀!8/0& ?& ∀!8∋05& ∃∀& (/0& 3%/.∃0/0& ∃∀& 7−∃& 0∃& 1∃#∃%4!∀∃∀& 0−0& 1∃%∃.Ε/0 Β&
Υ!.Ε/&1∃%∃.Ε/&1∃,∃&0∃%&!∀#∃%3%∃#∋1/&∋&(∋&(−2&1∃(&∋%#>.−(/&ΛΜ&1∃&(∋&Ι/∀6∃∀.!=∀&0/,%∃&(/0&Υ∃%∃.Ε/0&1∃(&Ω!8/5&∃(&.−∋(&
./∀#!∃∀∃&∋1∃.−∋1∋0&3%∃6!0!/∀∃0&0/,%∃&∃(&1∃%∃.Ε/&∋&0∃%&∃0.−.Ε∋1/&1∃&(∋0&∀!8∋0&?&(/0&∀!8/05&./∀&∃(&/,Γ∃#/&1∃&7−∃&(∋&
!∀#∃%6∃∀.!=∀&1∃(&∀!8/&0∃&∋Γ−0#∃&∋&(∋0&./∀1!.!/∀∃0&1∃&Α0#∃&?&∀/&%∃1−∀1∃&∃∀&3∃%Γ−!.!/&1∃&0−&!∀#∃%Α0&≅∃∀−!∀/Ξ∆#φ#!#∗∋(
Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu1#∋9((∆#0[ηγ
!∀#7,∀%∃76∃∀7)8#6∀8#&8(∃8#)∗∋(∃%7)∀−)Α2∃#Κ6∃#−∃Α∃#(∃82)Γ8(%∃#∋8(8#−∃&∃(∗)∀8(#%)#∃Χ∃7&)Ε8∗∃∀&∃#28#−∃Χ∃∀%8#;∃∀Ο()78#
7,)∀7)−∃#7,∀#2,%#)∀&∃(∃%∃%#)∀−)Ε)−682∃%#−∃#28%#∀)Μ8%#?#∀)Μ,%#)∀Ε,267(8−,%1#∃%#∋(∃7)%8∗∃∀&∃#;8(8∀&)Γ8(2∃%#∃2#−∃(∃7=,#8#%∃(#,4−,%∆#
Θ∃#−∃%&878#∋,(#∋8(&∃#−∃#28#&∃#Κ6∃#∃∀#∃%&∃#78%,#28%#∀)Μ8%#Χ6∃(,∀#∃%767=8−8%#∃∀#∋()∗∃(8#)∀%&8∀7)81#∀,#8%4#8∀&∃#28#
_⊥∆#δ∃%∃#8#28#8∋(∃7)87)Φ∀#−∃#28##∃∀#(∃287)Φ∀#8#Κ6∃#28#∀,#∀∃7∃%8()8∗∃∀&∃#&∃∀48#28#
,Α2);87)Φ∀#−∃#∃%767=8(#∀6∃Ε8∗∃∀&∃#8#28%#∀)Μ8%#φ&,∗8∀−,#∃∀#76∃∀&8#28#∀8&6(82∃Γ8#∋8(&)7628(#−∃2#(∃76(%,#−∃#Κ6∃ϑ8γ1#%4#7,∀%)−∃(8#
Κ6∃#%6#−∃(∃7=,#8#%∃(#,4−8%#Χ6∃#Ε62∀∃(8−,#∃∀#Ε)(&6−#−∃#Κ6∃#∃%767=8(#8#28%#∀)Μ8%#)∗∋2)78#7,∀%)−∃(8(#%6%#,∋)∀),∀∃%#?#∃∀#∃2#78%,#
∃∀#7,∗∃∀&,1#28#_ηΨ#
)ϑ∋&Ι/%#∃&./∀0#∋#∋&7−∃&(∋&Ι/%#∃&Ξ−3%∃4∋&1∃&Ψ−0#!.!∋&∀/&∃∆3(!.=&∃∀&0−&0∃∀#∃∀.!∋&.=4/&∃6∋(−=&//4=&∃∀&
.−∃∀#∋& (∋0& 1∃.(∋%∋.!/∀∃0& ?& 3%∃αβχ&
Ρ/%&∃(&./∀#%∋%!/5&(∋&Ι/%#∃&Ξ−3%∃4∋&0∃&(!4!#=&∋& ∃(&0−3−∃0#/&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&1∃&(∋0&#%∃0&
4∃∀/%∃0&1∃&∃1∋1&3∃%/&0!∀&4/#!6∋%&/&#!4/&./∀#%∋1∃.!%&(∋&6/(−∀#∋1&
∃∆3%∃0∋1∋&3/%& (∋0& ∀!8∋0& 1−%∋∀# ∃& ∃(& 3%/.∃0/&1∃& #−!.!=∀5& 4:0& ∋Η∀& 0!& 0∃& #!∃∀∃& ∃∀& .−∃∀#∋& (∋& !∀#∃%%∃(∋.!=∀& ∃∀#%∃& ∃(&
1∃%∃.Ε/&∋&3∋%#!.!3∋%&1∃&(/0&∀!8/0&?&∀!8∋0&?&∃(&/,Γ∃#!6/&1∃&.−43(!%&./∀&∃(&3%!∀.!3!/&1∃(&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&1∃(&∀!8/ΦΒ!#∗∋(
Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu1#∋9((∆#./∴γ
!%#∋(∃7)%,#−∃%&878(1#Κ6∃#∃∀#7,∀,7)∗)∃∀&,#−∃2#78%,#Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu1#28##,Α%∃(ΕΦ#Κ6∃#&8∀&,#28#∗8−(∃#7,∗,#
∃2#∋8−(∃#−∃#28%#∀)Μ8%#82∃;8Α8∀#&∃∀∃(#28#(∃∋(∃%∃∀&87)Φ∀#−∃#%6%#=)ϑ8%_∴∆#Ν(∃∀&∃#8#∃%&8#7,∀&(,Ε∃(%)81#28# ςΒ>#7,∀%)−∃(Φ#+&)2#
,(−∃∀8("eqoq"rtwgdc"rctc"oglqt"tguqnxgt."swg"c"ncu"pk‚cu"O0."X0"{"T0"hwgtcp"kphqtocfcu"uqdtg"uw"fgtgejq"c"ugt"qfcu"cpvg"
28# &∃#ςΒ>#?#28%#7,∀%∃76∃∀7)8%#Κ6∃#∃2#∃ϑ∃(7)7),#−∃#−)7=,#−∃(∃7=,#)∗∋2)78_[∆#!∀#∃2#−∃%8((,22,#−∃2#∋(,7∃%,#%∃#−∃%);∀Φ#6∀8#
−∃2∃;87)Φ∀#−∃#28##Κ6)∃∀#∃%767=Φ#8#−,%#−∃#28%#∀)Μ8%#∃∀#28#7)6−8−#−∃#Θ8∀&)8;,1#∃∀#782)−8−#−∃#Ε)7&)∗8%1#∃2#Χ6∀−8∗∃∀&,#
6&)2)Γ8−,#∋,(#28#Ζ/∆#
Nc"chgevcek„p"fg"nc"ukvwcek„p"lwtfkec"fg"nc"rgtuqpc"kpxqnwetcfc"(
03(0∀(6/∋10∗∋(1∋5∋(/0Ψ∃&∗&2∋(6#/#(%020/5&3#/(0∀(6∀#Γ∋(/#Γ∋3#Μ∀0
Nc" Eqtvg" KFJ" jc" fglcfq" gp" enctq" swg" gn" eqpegrvq" fg" rnc¦q" tc¦qpcdng" pq" tguwnvc" fg" ugpeknnc" fgÝpkek„pΖ0∆# Β)%&)∀;6)(#
∃∀&(∃#−6(87)Φ∀#(8Γ,∀8Α2∃#?#∋(,2,∀;87)Φ∀#)∀−∃Α)−8#−∃2#∋(,7∃%,#∃%#(∃2∃Ε8∀&∃#∋,(Κ6∃#∃%&,#+2&)∗,#7,∀%&)&6?∃1#∋,(#%4#∗)%∗81#6∀8#
Ε),287)Φ∀#−∃#28%#;8(8∀&48%#ϑ6−)7)82∃%Ζ.∆#!∀#2,%#(∃)&∃(8−,%#78%,%#−,∀−∃#28##%∃#=8#∋(,∀6∀7)8−,#%,Α(∃#∃2#∋28Γ,#(8Γ,∀8Α2∃1#
∃%#∋(∃7)%,#−∃7)(1#Κ6∃#∋8(8#∃%&∃#7,∗∃&)−,#28##=8#7,∗∋8(&)−,#∃2#7()&∃(),#−∃#28#6∗8∀,%Ζ_∆#!∀#
%6#ϑ6()%∋(6−∃∀7)8#)∀)7)82#28#∃∀#76∃∀&8#&(∃%#∃2∃∗∃∀&,%#∋8(8#−∃&∃(∗)∀8(#28#(8Γ,∀8Α)2)−8−#
−∃2#∋28Γ,Ψ#8γ#28#7,∗∋2∃ϑ)−8−#−∃2#8%6∀&,Η#Αγ#28#87&)Ε)−8−#∋(,7∃%82#−∃2#)∀&∃(∃%8−,Η#?#7γ#28#7,∀−67&8#−∃#28%#86&,()−8−∃%#ϑ6−)7)82∃%ΖΖ∆#
:#∋8(&)(#−∃2#78%,#Ο#∀∀0(α#/#5&∀∀∋1#∃∀&(∃#,&(,%Ζ⊥1#28# 7,∀%)−∃(8−,#6∀#768(&,#∃2∃∗∃∀&,Ψ#−γ#28#8Χ∃7&87)Φ∀#;∃∀∃(8−8#∃∀#28#
%)&687)Φ∀#ϑ6(4−)78#−∃#28#∋∃(%,∀8#)∀Ε,267(8−8#∃∀#∃2#∋(,7∃%,1#2,#7682#=8#%)−,#&(8&8−,#∃∀#6∀#Α,2∃&4∀#8∀&∃(),(Ζη
!∀#∃2#78%,#Hqtpgt„p"g"jklcΖε1#28##8∀82)Γ8#∃2#∋(,7∃%,#7,∀%)−∃(8∀−,#∃%&,%#Χ87&,(∃%#?#∃∀#(∃287)Φ∀#82#768(&,#∃2∃∗∃∀&,#
(∃%∃Μ8−,#∗9%#8(()Α8#=8#%∃Μ828−,Ψ#
Ωαβχ#αδχ∋%∋&1∃#∃%4!∀∋%&(∋&%∋2/∀∋,!(!1∋1&1∃(&3(∋2/∋4,!Α∀&0∃&1∃,∃&#/4∋%&∃∀&.−∃∀#∋&(∋&∋ ≅∃∀∃%∋1∋&
3/%&(∋&1−%∋.!=∀&1∃(&3%/.∃1!4!∃∀#/&∃∀&(∋&0!#−∋.!=∀&Γ−%>1!.∋&1∃&(∋&3∃%0/∀∋&!∀6/(−.%∋1∋&∃∀&∃(&4!04/5&./∀0!1∃%∋∀1/5&
∃∀#%∃&/#%/0&∃(∃4∃∀#/05&(∋&4∋#∃%!∋&/,Γ∃#/&1∃&./∀#%/6∃%0!∋Β&Χ0>5&∃(&+%!,−∀∋(&Ε∋&∃0#∋,(∃.!1/&7−∃&0!&∃(&3∋0/&1∃(&#!∃43/&
!∀.!1∃&1∃&4∋∀∃%∋&%∃(∃6∋∀#∃&∃∀&(∋&0!#−∋.!=∀&Γ−%>1!.∋&1∃(&!∀1!6!1−/5&%∃0−(#∋%:&∀∃.∃0∋%!/&7−∃&∃(&3%/.∃1!4!∃∀#/&∋6∋∀.∃&
eqp"oc{qt"fknkigpekc"c"Ýp"fg"swg"gn"ecuq"ug"tguwgnxc"gp"wp"vkgorq"dtgxg0
" Ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu"xu0"Ejkng."0−3%∋&∀,&8#__1#∋9((%∆#./Ζλ./⊥∆
# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#./η∆
# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#0.∆
" Ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu"xu0"Ejkng0"Tguqnwek„p"fg"nc"Eqtvg"Kpvgtcogtkecpc"fg"Fgtgejqu"Jwocpqu"fg"4;"fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"4233."rƒtt0";0"Fkurqpkdng"gp
,(∆7(π−,7%π8%6∀&,%π8&828ρ.[ρ00ρ000∆∋−Χ
<=# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#00∆#
?≅# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#0.∆#
# <8%,#Τ∃∀)∃#Σ878?,#Ε%∆#Ρ)78(8;68∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.[#−∃#∃∀∃(,#−∃#0[[ε∆#Θ∃()∃#
?;# <8%,#>)28)(∃1# ?#3∃∀ϑ8∗)∀#?#,&(,%#Ε%∆#Υ()∀)−8−#?#Υ,Α8;,∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.0#−∃#ϑ6∀),#−∃#.//.∆#Θ∃()∃# ∋9((∆#0Ζ⊥Η#<8%,#0[#
Ugpvgpekc"fg"7"fg"lwnkq"fg"42260"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"32;."rƒtt0"3;3="Ecuq"Iqp¦ƒng¦"Ogfkpc"{"hcoknkctgu"xu0"Tgr¿dnkec"Fqokpkecpc."0−3%∋#∀,&8#./1#∋9((∆#.⊥εΗ#<8%,#Ν,(∀∃(Φ∀#∃#=)ϑ8#
Ε%∆#:(;∃∀&)∀8∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.ε#−∃#8Α()2#−∃#./0.∆#Θ∃()∃#!
?<" Xgt"gpvtg"qvtqu."EGFJ."Ecug"Oqvvc"xu0"Kvcn{0"Lwfiogpv"qh"3;"Hgdtwct{"3;;3."rƒtt0"52"{"EGFJ."Ecug"Twk¦"Ocvgqu"xu0"Urckp0"Lwfiogpv"qh"45"Lwpg"3;;5."rƒtt0"520
??# <8%,#Τ∃∀)∃#Σ878?,#Ε%∆#Ρ)78(8;681#0−3%∋#∀,&8#Ζ0Η#<8%,#≅)78(−,#<8∀∃%∃#Ε%∆#δ8(8;68?∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#_0#−∃#8;,%&,#−∃#.//Ζ∆#Θ∃()∃#∆#0Ζ0Η#<8%,#Υ)Α)#Ε%∆#!768−,(1#
0−3%∋#∀,&8#0Ζ#∋9((∆#0ε⊥Η#<8%,#>∃(∗8∀8%#Θ∃((8∀,#∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#0#−∃#∗8(Γ,#−∃#.//⊥∆#Θ∃()∃#
xu0"Rctciwc{0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"39"fg"lwpkq"fg"42270"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"347."rƒtt0"87="Ecuq"fg"nc"Eqowpkfcf"Oqkycpc"xu0"Uwtkpco0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"37"fg"lwpkq"fg"42270"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"346."
∋9((∆#0η/Η#<8%,#:7,%&8#<82−∃(Φ∀#Ε%∆#!768−,(∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.Ζ#−∃#ϑ6∀),#−∃#.//⊥∆#Θ∃()∃#Ρο#0.[1#∋9((∆#0/⊥Η#<8%,#Τ8(748#:%&,#?#≅8∗4(∃Γ#≅,ϑ8%#Ε%∆#δ∃(+∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#.⊥#−∃#
∀,Ε)∃∗Α(∃#−∃#.//⊥∆#Θ∃()∃#∆#0ηηΗ#<8%,#ΣΦ∋∃Γ#θ2Ε8(∃Γ#Ε%∆#>,∀−6(8%1#0−3%∋#∀,&8#0⊥1#∋9((∆#0_.Η#<8%,#382−∃Φ∀#Τ8(748#Ε%∆#δ∃(+∆#Θ∃∀&∃∀7)8#−∃#η#−∃#:Α()2#−∃#.//η∆#
Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"369."rƒtt0"373="Ecuq"fg"nc"Ocucetg"fg"Rwgdnq"Dgnnq"xu0"Eqnqodkc0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"3"fg"lwnkq"fg"42280"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"362."rƒtt0"3930
# <8%,#]822∃#58(8∗)22,#?#,&(,%#Ε%∆#
Rctciwc{0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"46"fg"ciquvq"fg"42320"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"436."rƒtt0"358"{"Ecuq"N„rg¦"Ogpfq¦c"xu0"Xgpg¦wgnc0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"3"fg"ugrvkgodtg"fg"42330"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"455."
∋9((∆#0ε[∆
# 3,2∃&4∀#−∃#56()%∋(6−∃∀7)8#−∃#28#6∗8∀,%∆#6∗8∀,%1#Ν8762&8−#−∃#Β∃(∃7=,1#Ι∀)Ε∃(%)−8−#−∃#<=)2∃1#Ρο#.π./00∆
# <8%,#Ν,(∀∃(Φ∀#∃#=)ϑ8#Ε%∆#:(;∃∀&)∀81#0−3%∋#∀,&8#Ζ.∆#
6#)∗∀!&!+.%∗∋∗(∋∗#9Α∋(∀∋∀∗−∗/%∗∀#,+
!!
+∋∀#/&∃(&Ψ−∃2&1∃&Ρ%!4∃%∋&Ζ∀0#∋∀.!∋&./4/&∃(&Ξ−3∃%!/%&+%!,−∀∋(&1∃&∗∀#%∃&Τ>/0&/#/%≅∋%/∀&(∋&≅−∋%1∋&Γ−1!.!∋(&1∃&
(∋&∀!8∋&∋(&4∋#%!4/∀!/&[∴]&./∀&,∋0∃5&3%!∀.!3∋(4∃∀#∃5&∃∀&(/0&6>∀.−(/0&7−∃&Ε∋,>∋&1∃0∋%%/((∋1/&;&./∀&∃(&4∋#%!4/∀!/&
1∃&≅−∋%1∋&./∀&∃(&#%∋∀0.−%%!%&1∃(&#!∃43/Β&∗0#/&!43(!.=&7−∃5&3∃0∃&∋&7−∃&∃(&0∃8/%&⊥/%∀∃%=∀&∃0&∃(&3∋1%∃&,!/(=≅!./&1∃&
(∋&∀!8∋5&_?&∋0>&(/&%∃./∀/.!=&∋∀#∃&(∋0&∋−#/%!1∋1∃0&1∃01∃&3/./&1∃03−Α0&1∃&0−&∀∋.!4!∃∀#/_5&∀/&Ε∋&3/1!1/&∃Γ∃%.∃%&
0−0&1∃%∃.Ε/0&∀!&.−43(!%&./∀&0−0&1∃,∃%∃0&1∃&3∋1%∃5&∀!&;&Ε∋&3/1!1/&1!0 1∃%∃.Ε/0&7−∃&(∃&./%%∃03/∀1∃∀&
./4/&∀!8∋&%∃03∃.#/&1∃&0−& ∃5&(∋&∋−0∃∀.!∋&1∃&−∀∋&1∃.!0!=∀&?&∃0#∋,(∃.!4!∃∀#/&1∃&−∀&
%Α≅!4∃∀&1∃&6!0!#∋0&Ε∋&!43∃1!1/&7−∃&3∋1%∃&∃&Ε!Γ∋&0∃&./∀/2.∋∀&?&7−∃&0∃&∃0#∋,(∃2.∋&−∀&6>∀.−(/&∃∀#%∃&∋4,/05&∃((/&
∃∀&(/0&3%!4∃%/0&ΛΜ&∋8/0&1∃&6!1∋&1∃&(∋&∀!8∋5&∃#∋3∋& 0−&1∃0∋%%/((/Β&Ι/∀0∃.−∃∀#∃4∃∀#∃5∃∀!∃∀1/&∃∀&
ewgpvc"nqu"fgtgejqu"g"kpvgtgugu"gp"lwgiq."gn"tgvtcuq"gp"ncu"fgekukqpgu"lwfkekcngu"igpgt„"chgevcekqpgu"ukipkÝecvkxcu."
!%%∃6∃%0!,(∃0&∃&!%%∃4∃1!∋,(∃0&∋&(/0&1∃%∃.Ε/0&1∃(&0∃8/%&⊥/%∀∃%=∀&?&1∃&0−&Ε!Γ∋Φ∆#φ!#∗∋#Hqtpgt„p"g"jklc1#∋9((%∆#ε⊥#?#εηγ
ι&(,#8%∋∃7&,#(∃287),∀8−,#7,∀#28#∋(,2,∀;87)Φ∀#)∀−∃Α)−8#−∃2#∋(,7∃%,#∃%#∃2#Κ6∃#,Α%∃(Ε8#28# ςΒ>#82#%∃Μ828(#Κ6∃1#28#
−∃∗,(8#∃∀#∃2#∋(,7∃%,#?#∃2#&(8∀%76(%,#−∃2#&)∃∗∋,#7,∀%&)&6?∃(,∀#6∀#Χ6∀−8∗∃∀&,#−∃&∃(∗)∀8∀&∃#∋8(8#Κ6∃#∃2#&()Α6∀82#∀87),∀82#
(∃%,2Ε)∃(8#28#7,∀&(,Ε∃(%)8#82∃;8∀−,#∃2#)∀&∃(Ο%#%6∋∃(),(#−∃#28#∀)Μ8Ζ∴∆#:2#(∃%∋∃7&,#28##8−Ε)∃(&∃#Κ6∃Ψ
)∗0#∃&+%!,−∀∋(&./∀0!1∃%∋&7−∃&(∋&/,0∃%6∋∀.!∋&1∃&(∋0&1!03/0!.!/∀∃0&(∃≅∋(∃0&?&(∋&1!(!≅∃∀.!∋&∃∀&(/0&3%/.∃1!4!∃∀#/0&
Γ−1!.!∋(∃0& 0/∀& ∃(∃4∃∀#/0&
!∀6/.∋%0∃&∃(&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&1∃(&∀!8/&3∋%∋&(∃≅!#!4∋%&(∋&!∀/,0∃%6∋∀.!∋&1∃&%∃7−!0!#/0&(∃≅∋(∃05&(∋&1∃4/%∋&/&∃%%/%∃0&∃∀&
(/0&3%/.∃1!4!∃∀#/0&Γ−1!.!∋(∃0ΦΒ!#∗∋#Hqtpgt„p"g"jklc1#∋9((∆#0/⊥γ
Ρ56/∋10%031(%0(&3∆∋1#/(0∀(&320/∴∗(∗∃60/&∋/(%0∀(3&∋(6#/#(∀0Χ&2&5#/(∃3#(∗&2∃#1&Ε3(%0(%&∗1/&5&3#1&Ε3
#
Σ8##%∃#=8#∋(,∀6∀7)8−,#∃∀#(∃∋∃&)−8%#,78%),∀∃%#%,Α(∃#2,%#−∃(∃7=,%#−∃#2,%#∀)Μ,%#?#∀)Μ8%#?#∋8(&)7628(∗∃∀&∃#%,Α(∃#
∃2#∋()∀7)∋),#78(−)∀82#−∃2#)∀&∃(Ο%#%6∋∃(),(#−∃2#∀)Μ,Ζ[∆#!∀#∃2#ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu⊥/#28#
vtkdwpcngu"pcekqpcngu"fg"guvg"rtkpekrkq"cn"fgekfkt"cegtec"fg"nc"ewuvqfkc"{"vwkekqp"fg"ncu"pk‚cu"{"cÝtoc"swg"cn"kpxqect"{"crnkect"
∃%&∃#∋()∀7)∋),#−∃Α∃#=87∃(%∃#−∃#Χ,(∗8#Κ6∃#∋∃(∗)&8#∃2#;,Γ∃#−∃#&,−,%#2,%#−∃(∃7=,%#=6∗8∀,%#%)∀#−)%7()∗)∀87)Φ∀#82;6∀8Ψ
#Ωα!χ∀&.−∋∀#/&∋(&∋%≅−4∃∀#/&1∃&7−∃&∃(&3%!∀.!3!/&1∃(&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&1∃(&∀!8/&3−∃1∃&6∃%0∃&
1∃&−∀&%∃.Ε∋2/&3/%&(∋&0/.!∃1∋15&(∋&Ι/%#∃&./∀0!1∃%∋&7−∃&−∀&3/0!,(∃&∃0#!≅4∋&0/.!∋(&1∃,!1/&∋&(∋&/%!∃∀#∋.!=∀&0∃∆−∋(&1∃&
(∋&4∋1%∃&/&∃(&3∋1%∃&∀/&3−∃1∃&./∀0!1∃%∋%0∃&−∀&Π1∋8/Θ&6:(!1/&∋&(/0&∃ ∃%4!∀∋.!=∀&1∃(&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&
1∃(&∀!8/Β&Ξ!&(/0&Γ−∃.∃0&7−∃&∋∀∋(!2∋∀&.∋0/0&./4/&∃(&3%∃0∃∀#∃&./∀0#∋#∋∀&(∋&∃∆!0#∃∀.!∋&1∃&1!0.%!4!∀∋.!=∀&0/.!∋(&∃0&
#/#∋(4∃∀#∃&!∀∋14!0!,(∃&(∃≅!#!4∋%&∃0∋&1!0.%!4!∀∋.!=∀&./∀&∃(&∋%≅−4∃∀#/&1∃&3%/#∃≅∃%&∃(&!∀#∃%Α0&0−3∃%!/%&1∃(&4∃∀/%&1∃&
∃1∋1Ξ∆#φEcuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu1#∋9((∆#0.0γ
Nc"Eqtvg"KFJ"uquvkgpg"swg"gn"ctiwogpvq"fg"nc"rqukdng"fkuetkokpcek„p"uqekcn"pq"gtc"cfgewcfq"rctc"ewornkt"eqp"nc"Ýpcnkfcf"
−∃728(8−8#−∃#∋(,&∃;∃(#∃2#)∀&∃(Ο%#%6∋∃(),(#−∃#28%#∀)Μ8%#7,∗,#=8Α48#8(;τ)−,#28#
&()Α6∀82#∀87),∀82#∀,#76∗∋2)Φ#2,%#(∃Κ6)%)&,%#−∃#6∀#&∃%)((∃%&()7&,1#(∃%∋∃7&,#−∃#28#786%82)−8−#∃∀&(∃#28#7,∀Ε)Ε∃∀7)8#−∃#%6#∗8−(∃#7,∀#
6∀8#∋8(∃ϑ8#−∃2#∗)%∗,#%∃Λ,#?#6∀8#%6∋6∃%&8#8Χ∃7&87)Φ∀#−∃#28%#7,∀−)7),∀∃%#−∃#−∃%8((,22,#−∃#28%#∀)Μ8%⊥0
!∀#∃2#ecuq"Hqtpgt„p"g"jklc."nc"Eqtvg"ug"dcu„"uqdtg"nq"cpvgtkqtogpvg"guvcdngekfq"gp"gn"ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu"citgicpfq"
Κ6∃#Ω∃2#Υ()Α6∀82#7,∀%)−∃(8#Κ6∃#∃2#)∀&∃(Ο%#%6∋∃(),(#−∃2#∀)Μ,#∀,#∋6∃−∃#%∃(#6&)2)Γ8−,#∋8(8#∀∃;8(#∃2#−∃(∃7=,#−∃#%6#∋(,;∃∀)&,(#∋,(#%6#
guvcfq"ekxkn."gp"dgpgÝekq"fg"cswgnnqu"swg"ewgpvcp"eqp"wp"guvcfq"ekxkn"swg"ug"clwuvc"c"wp"fgvgtokpcfq"eqpegrvq"fg"hcoknkcÒ⊥.∆#
Ρ3∆0/∗&Ε3(%0(∀#(1#/Χ#(%0(∀#(6/∃0Μ#(03(1#∗∋∗(%0(%&∗1/&5&3#1&Ε3(
!∀#78%,%#768∀−,#%∃#82∃;8#6∀#&(8&,#−)Χ∃(∃∀7)8−,#Α8%8−,#%,Α(∃#78&∃;,(48%#∋(,&∃;)−8%1#∃∀#∃%&∃#78%,#∋,(#,()∃∀&87)Φ∀#
%∃Λ6821#28#
)+%∋#:∀1/0∃&1∃&(∋&3%/Ε!,!.!=∀&1∃&1!0.%!4!∀∋.!=∀&3/%&/%!∃∀#∋.!=∀&0∃∆−∋(5&(∋&∃6∃∀#−∋(&%∃0#%!..!=∀&1∃&−∀&1∃%∃.Ε/&
gzkig"wpc"hwpfcogpvcek„p"tkiwtquc"{"fg"owejq"rguq."kpxktvkf‌ipfqug."cfgoƒu."nc"ectic"fg"nc"rtwgdc."nq"swg"ukipkÝec"
7−∃&./%%∃03/∀1∃&∋&(∋&∋−#/%!1∋1&1∃4/0#%∋%&7−∃&0−&1∃.!0!=∀&∀/&#∃∀>∋&−∀&3%/3=0!#/&∀!&−∀&∃ /&1!0.%!4!∀∋#/%!/ΦΒ#
φEcuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"{"pk‚cu1#∋9((∆#0.Ζγ
ν#8;(∃;8#Κ6∃Ψ
)∗∀&∃ ∃(&∗0#∋1/&∃(&7−∃&#!∃∀∃&(∋&.∋%≅∋&1∃&(∋&3%−∃,∋&3∋%∋&4/0#%∋%&7−∃&(∋&1∃.!0!=∀&Γ−1!.!∋(&/,Γ∃#/&1∃(&
fgdcvg"ug"jc"dcucfq"gp"nc"gzkuvgpekc"fg"wp"fc‚q"eqpetgvq."gurgeÝeq"{"tgcn"gp"gn"fgucttqnnq"fg"ncu"pk‚cu0"Rctc"
gnnq"gu"pgeguctkq"swg"gp"ncu"fgekukqpgu"lwfkekcngu"uqdtg"guvqu"vgocu"ug"fgÝpcp"fg"ocpgtc"gurgeÝec"{"eqpetgvc"
(/0&∃(∃4∃∀#/0&1∃&./∀∃∆!1∋1&?&.∋−0∋(!1∋1&∃∀#%∃&(∋&./∀1−.#∋&1∃&(∋&4∋1%∃&/&∃(&3∋1%∃&?&∃(&0−3−∃0#/&!43∋.#/&∃∀&∃(&
1∃0∋%%/((/&1∃(&∀!8/Β&Υ∃&(/&./∀#%∋%!/5&0∃&./%%∃&∃(&%!∃0≅/&1∃& 1∃.!0!=∀&∃∀&−∀&∃0#∃%∃/#!3/&0−3%∋&3:%%0Β&
ΛΣα&?&ΛΛΛβ&6!∀.−(∋1/&∃∆.(−0!6∋4∃∀#∃&∋&(∋&3%∃∴./∀.∃3.!=∀5&∀/&0−0#∃∀#∋1∋5&1∃&7−∃&(/0&∀!8/0&.%!∋1/0&3/%&3∋%∃Γ∋0&
jqoqugzwcngu"pgeguctkcogpvg"vgpftcp"fkÝewnvcfgu"rctc"fgÝpkt"tqngu"fg"if‌ipgtq"q"ugzwcnguÒ0"φEcuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"{"
3&#∗1#∋9((∆#0.⊥γ
# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#0/Ζ∆#
?=# <8%,#36287),#Ε%∆#:(;∃∀&)∀81#0−3%∋&∀,&8#.η1#∋9((∆#0_ΖΗ#<8%,#−∃#28#∃#:Λ8#Ε%∆#δ8(8;68?1#0−3%∋#∀,&8#ΖΖ1#∋9((∆#0ε.Η#<8%,#−∃#28%#Ρ)Μ8%#ν∃8∀#?#3,%)7,#
xu0"Tgr¿dnkec"Fqokpkecpc0"Ugpvgpekc"fg":"fg"ugrvkgodtg"fg"42270"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"352."rƒtt0"3560"Ecuq"Tqugpfq"Ecpv¿"{"qvtc"xu0"Of‌izkeq."0−3%∋#∀,&8#0ε1#∋9((∆#./0∆#<8%,#
Iqp¦ƒng¦"{"qvtcu"*ÑEcorq"CniqfqpgtqÒ+"xu0"Of‌izkeq0"Ugpvgpekc"fg"38"fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"422;0"Ugtkg"E"Ṗ"427."rƒtt0"62:0"
Τ≅" Ecuq"Cvcnc"Tkq"g"jklcu"xu0"Ejkng."0−3%∋#∀,&8#__1#∋9((%∆#0/[λ000∆##
ΤΑ# ςΑ4−∃∗1#∋9((∆#0_0∆##
Τ;( <8%,#Ν,(∀∃(Φ∀#∃#=)ϑ8#Ε%∆#:(;∃∀&)∀81#0−3%∋#∀,&8#Ζ.1#∋9((∆#[[∆

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex