Copyleft, -right and the case law on APIs on both sides of the Atlantic
Author | Walter van Holst |
Position | (with thanks to the whole of the FTF-legal mailinglist for contributing information and cases that were essential for this article) |
Pages | 5-13 |
!
∀!
#
! ∀∀#!∃!%&
∋∃(
(((!)∃∗
(
+(+!
,∃−
.−−−/
∃
∗00#1
!∗−
−(∃−
2(00#13((
∃−−+4∋5
(!,(−
−!
6670(06
666∗(6∃6
70(08∃ 9!(
:
(((( 2(
. 4∃ 5 / ∗! ,
(7008 (( (!0
− −.∃&∀/
+ (∃ (
( 2(!,∗(
∃ )( ;.00
(∃1/;0.∃−/!,(3
∃ −
∃ 3((! , (
−−!
( −
( ((
( (. / ./−
!(( ∋ );
0 ∃ . (
(3((/ 3( ;0 ∋ (
∃!
( −(( !,∃
( ( ! ,( ∃
( ! & −∃∀ 4, ∗ (
(((5!,(
(∃(
∃%!&&∀! ∋!( &
&!!&&&∀&
& ) ∗
& ! ! + & )
∀&&)&
∗∋!,
− ∃∀ . − ∃& &
/
∃−!
∀& . !∀
! ! !
∀ !! ∃, !
& ! !(
∀&!
70(08∃ 9!(
%
∗&,
,∗(−∋( 4(∗
∃ ∋5! ∃ ∋ !
∃ ∃ − ∋
=
0 −∃&∗(
∃− & ∀ ! ∀&
∗)& ∋!
! ∋! &
∀ ∋! ∀! ∀& ∋!#
∋!∃
0 ( 0 − ∃∀6∃
( . (
(∋/∗!
, ( 7 0 7(.707/ −
(
( !& , ∃
3( ∃ 3( ∗
− ∋ ∃
(∋ !, ( ∃ 3(
∋ ∃
( !>
∃ (
(!
, ( ( ∃∃ ∋
( − ∃ (
∃ ! ?); 0∃ !
% ;0 ≅ Α%: .;0≅/ ∃ ( ∃
!( (3 ∃ ∗
0(+∃∃(;0!∀
0 ∃ ( ++ (3 ( ∃∃ ∋
(!&(∀>≅∃∃∃∋
∃!! &
Β)!.& /)−?;−##!(!##!!
7−∋0ΧΒ!.& /,(∗∆
∃∃∋∃−?;−>;∃8∃9Ε!
& !<<
& 0∗∆Β∋.& Α/+Φ∃ΓΧΓΗ)∃+
700!8∃!./∋Φ
0(+700!8∃!./&%Η∀&!
∀ 0(!.& &/,Ι(0(≅≅+∃∃1∋8.((&Α& &/!
−Φ(76;≅>∋(8?!&∀Ε∃008?
##!#ϑ&∀Ε
70(08∃ 9!(
Ε
∀ /
&,
≅∃( (>≅∃ ∃
∗ ! ;0≅ ! ∀ ( (( ./ ! &∀
−;Χ(.;∆−/!&;Γ≅ΑΕΕ!
,∃ ∃ ++
∋!
,−∃∀
∃%!& & ∀ ∋! !
!∋!!!0,
(((
∃#%! ∗ &
! & ∗ & &
∀ + !
& ∗ !
& & ∀ ! &
&,
,(∃−∃∀(
∃121 ∋∀∗ !& !
&! & ! ∀ ∀&& !&
!! & ∀&
& 12 ∗1 ∋∀∗ ∗
345666&6&!7,
0&−∃&−∃&∃(!
( (− (
∃∃∋ ∗ ( (
(!,(( −.∃&∃∀/
( ! − 4≅ ∋5
−∃∀(!,
2( +(∋ +
( ! ,
.−/((
(( 0& − ( ∗(
∃!
> ∗
∋ !
70(08∃ 9!(
Α
(
./!,( (∋ ( (
( (./ ! ,
∃ (!, ∋
∋∋ ( ∋ ! ,
∃ (∋ .(∃
/ ∃ ( !, ∋! (
( ( ∋ ∃
! ∃ ∗ (( ∃∃ (
∗ ( (
(!<
( ∃ ∋ ∗
(
∗ (( . 3( (
∃∋ /!, ( ( ((
∋ ++ (
(!
( (
( ∋ ( Φ∃ ∃∋ !?), ( ∃(
( Φ(,.Φ,/((
∃∃∋
( ( ∃(! )∃
(( ∆Φ∃0
.)≅Β/ 8(( ( ∃
∃!
? ∋ ( ∋
∃ ( ∋ ∃ ( (
∋ ∋ ∗(!1∋ ( ∃∃∋
∗( . ∋
/! , ( 2( ∃∃ ∋ .
/ ∗( ∗ ! ∗ ;0 !
!! !∀ &7!∀ Ε .% ≅!ΑΑ%/! ∋ 1
!8!,!≅ ( ∋
.∃ ∗ / !
( ∃∃ ∋!8!,!≅
∗(! ,% ≅(≅( (
≅(+ ∃ ∗( #
∃% !! &&!! !∀ Ε: 7!&∀ .Α ≅! ΑΕΕ/: Α ≅(
≅( ! Α ≅( 41(
( ∃(
!5 ! ;0≅
< !.& :/(Η0≅∃∃1∋=(
)∗(∋;≅≅,−&>∋
,Φ(
(##!!!(###&Κ7∀ΚΕ !
: ,(##(∋!(!#(!∃##7Ε:#Ε:!7&!∀
70(08∃ 9!(
∋∃!
≅ ∃ ∋
∃!Α%%7!& .Α≅!ΑΑ&/%∋∀ ∃%!!
∀( ∀! & ∀ 7!∀ Α: .Α ≅! & /Ε %! !)
!Α:≅!ΑΑ&/!Α0( (
!,
( ∃ !0Χ (
4 (
(
∋((Χ∋5! 9∋0?
≅( ≅( ( ( ( (
0+ ( ( ( (
( 0 ∃∃! ≅∗ (
0+ 0 ∃
(6 ( ( ∗ ∃ ≅∗+
( ∃∃∋ 0+ 0!
? ≅( ( ( 0+
∃! 7 ( ∃∃ ∋ ∃ 3((
∃( ∗ 2(! 0Χ
∃ 3( ∗ ( ∋ ∃ (
≅∗!
7 ( (
3(( 2(∃ ;
0!7 ∗ & ( ∆ ≅( ( ( (
((8∃ ∃(
( ∃! ∆≅( (
(+
∃ ∋ ! 1
2(( ∃
∋((! )2(;03((
∗∀ ? ∃ Β ∃
2(2( ∃( (
∃∃ ∋ ∗( ! ∃
( ∗ ∋ − + <
(∋ (!, ;0≅(
∆( ∋ ∃ (
(∋ ( . /
( (
(!
3(( ( (
% 8∃##(∋!(!#(!∃##7Α%%#Α%%!7&! !Α&:!
Ε 8∃##(∋!(!#(!∃##7∀#& ∀#& ∀!7∀!Α:!ΑΑΕ&!
Α 8∃##(∋!(!#(!∃##7Α:
0Χ!
11∃!90:Ε7!0(!∀.ΑΕ:/Β0∃!7−!
%.Α≅!ΑΑΕ/−!
& ∆8Α3(Α%Α?ΦΑ%ΑΑΕ !∀!!≅Φ!
∀ 88&&& ∃Λ∃(∆>∀3(& &∆
& ! %Α!::9 %%∀(##!∋!#3!=3ϑ>9 %%∀
< −∆(;∃ ! !& .;Ε:# /8?!& ∀#:Ε&
70(08∃ 9!(
∋∃2(∃∃∋
∃ (( ( ∋ !
( 3( ∃(
∃ ( ( ( ∃
!
, 45 Β (
∋!> ∃ (∋ ∋ (
45 ∋ (+ ( (! ,
( ( !
)∗ 45 ∋ ( ∋
(((
∃∃ !7 ∗ ∋
∋ ! , ∗ ( .−;/
!(
∋ )(( 2( ∃(
(∋((((3
!
, 2( ∋∋∗, . );/
−∗:.;0/ !,(
#− ( ;0
!
00#1 2(
( (
! , ∃ ∗ ( ∋ ∗
( ∃ ( . ∃/ ( 9ΧΧ%
( ∗ ! , )( ≅( Φ( .)≅Φ/
(( ./01Ε (
( 0 ∃.Α#& )≅/ ( (
∗(
∃89&:; −;=#>?;6=
!∀ ! & !!
!! ! !
! . ! .
! ∀&& ! !
,!!#
, )( ≅∃ ( + (+ (
.∃ (/(( ( .
/ ( (
0 ∃ .Α#& )≅/! ∗(
∃ (∃ (
00(!∃1)≅ΦΒ&& &≅< :# ∃
##(!(!(#3(#(#(!3=
∗ϑΛϑ&&∀:&Λ∗ϑ Λϑ)?Λϑ2ΛϑΛϑΛϑΛϑΑ%&
: ;0≅(?≅?!≅ ∀:1∆
% 9ΧΧ0!.& &/≅∃Φ,)≅∀!∀!!
Ε >ΧΜΝ∃Ο)≅Φ&&& ≅∀Α∀# Α∃
##(!(!(#3(#(#(!3=
∗ϑΛϑΕ∀
70(08∃ 9!(
&
(∋!,(2(
( − −
!
7 ( 2( ( −
./∋ )≅Φ+ ∃ (
! >( ∃
(
0∃.Α#& )≅/(((++!,
∗ ∃∋∃(−
./−∃ ! ∃
∋.(
−∃ / (
( − ! ( −+ ( ∗
(∃∃
∃!
( ( ;0
;0 ≅( ? ≅ ( )≅Φ
∃− 2(∃ !,
((
∃ 8& − !
!Α!!&∀
! ! !# ∀&
!!,
,( Φ∃ (
∗ (( (
(( ( ∃
!% ;0≅ 2(∃ )( 3(! )( ∗
(∋∃(
!(
( −∃ ( ( /
∋ ( ( (
/&−∃∀!
( ∃ 0Χ+ −∃&
2(∃!
∀
( − ( .
/./− (∋∃
−−( !
−∃ ∃∋
! , ( ∃∃
∋ ∃ ∃ 2(
− ( ( ./−
!2(2(∗(∃(
70(08∃ 9!(
∀
∃∃ ∋ 45 ∃!1
( ∋ ( (
∋ 3(( Χ! 7(
(∋
( ( ( ∃!1
∋ 3(( ( ( −
− ( − ( (
∃2( −! (
( ∋ ( ( ((
∃.&! / ∃ .−∀! /( ((
(((−!
( ∗∃∃
− !, ∃
((!
566!#
70(08∃ 9!(
,(70(0
8∃9((.Β8≅∆& ∀/!
##!!!
,(
∆1∃.& ∀/+≅
+ Β
8∃./Η
! ∀∀#!∃!%&
≅Π& ∀1∃∆!
,(≅∃≅?.?/&!
∃∃∋(≅≅>Θ?∃
##∃!###&! #(∋#
∗(∗(
((∃(.
((/∋!,
((!