A constitucionalização do direito internacional no direito brasileiro

• Author: Leonardo Nemer Caldeira Brant
• Position: Pesquisador Bolsista do CNPq, produtividade em pesquisa, PQ2. Doutor em Direito Público pela Université Paris X Nanterre
• Pages: 64-159

1445(6789:7;8;!

!∀#∃%&∋()%∗+&,−&%∋(.−(/&%−&0∋(1∀0−%∀∗2&∋∀∗,3(1445(6789:7;8;3(<∋,=63(∀=(>?3(≅∗∀(.−(>9>9(

!

∃#1∗%,0)0&1)∗%∃−)⊥∃ΞΨ∗#/∗#/)(.)0∗#)%0.(%∃1)∗%∃−##

%∗#/)(.)0∗#+(∃,)−.)(∗#

!

∀#∃%&∋(∃!)#∗#∋!+&,(#−∋&!.∋&%/

∀#∃

!

#

Ρ!(−∋#−/∃!4∃%7/−/24−∃%&,!;∋&7−,#−∋∃!1#∗:!Ι−7/∃∋−4&∗#%/#:!−%4∃∋3∃∋&%(∃!&∃!7#2!/#ϑ/∃!

(#/#∋∗−%&ΝΟ#7! Β2#! ∃∋−#%/&∗! &7! 4∃∗3#/<%4−&7! 3&∋&! &! ∋#&,−Λ&ΝΦ∃! (#! &/∃7! 4∃∗! 1∃4&ΝΦ∃!

−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,:!;#∗!4∃∗∃!∃7!#,#∗#%/∃7!3∋Χ3∋−∃7!Η!∗&%2/#%ΝΦ∃!(&!3&Λ!#! &!4∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃! (∃!

(−∋#−/∃!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,8!!

Α77−∗:!Ι−7/∃∋−4&∗#%/#:!∃!7∆42,∃!∴Κ∴!/∋∃2ϑ#!/∋&%7?∃∋∗&ΝΟ#7!3∃,5/−4&7!∋#,#1&%/#7!Β2#!

%Φ∃! −∗3&4/&∋&∗! (#! ?∃∋∗&! 3∋∃?2%(&! &! %&/2∋#Λ&! (∃! (−∋#−/∃! −%/#∋%&4−∃%&,! 3∋#1−7/∃! %&7!

4∃%7/−/2−ΝΟ#7! ;∋&7−,#−∋&78! Α! 3∋−∗#−∋&! 4∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃! ;∋&7−,#−∋&:! 3∋∃∗2,≅&(&! #∗! ]⊥α:! ,∃≅∃!

&3Χ7! &! −%(#3#%(<%4−&! (#! ]⊥:! ∋#&?−∋∗∃2! &! 72&! −%(#3#%(<%4−&! 3#∋&%/#! ∃7! 97/&(∃7! #!

∃2/∃∋≅∃2:!&∃! Κ∗3#∋&(∃∋:!#∗!7#2! &∋/−≅∃!]_:!&! 4∃∗3#/<%4−&!3&∋&! %∃∗#&∋!#∗;&−ϑ&(∃∋#7!#!

&≅#%/#7! (−3,∃∗Π/−4∃7! #! 4∃∗#∋4−&−7:! (−∋−≅−∋! %#≅∃4−&ΝΟ#7! 3∃,5/−4&7! 4∃∗! ∃2/∋∃7! 97/&(∃7:!

(#4,&∋&∋!≅2#∋∋&!∃2!?&Λ#∋!&!3&Λ

∀#%

!#!?−∋∗&∋!/∋&/&(∃7

∀#&

8!Α!3∋−∗#−∋&!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!Ω#32;,−4&%&:!

!

∀#∃

!∀#∃%&∋∃()∗+! ,∗−∃∋∃.(! )∗! /0∀%1! 2+∗)&.∋3∋)()#! #4! 2#∃%&∋∃(1! ∀567! 8∗&.∗+! #4! 8∋+#∋.∗! ∀9:−∋;∗! 2#−(!

<=∋3#+∃∋.>!∀(+∋∃!?! 0(=.#++#7!≅#∃#!)#! )∗&.∗+()∗! −(&+#()(!;∗4! ∗!Α∀+∋Β!)&! Χ∋=∋∃.∆+#! )#!−(! Ε#;Φ#+;Φ#Α1! #4!

∀(+∋∃1!Γ+(=Η(7!Χ#∃.+()∗!#!Ι+()&(Ηϑ∗!#4!8∋+#∋.∗!2#−(!<=∋3#+∃∋)()#!Γ#)#+(−!)#!Χ∋=(∃!Κ#+(∋∃!Λ<ΓΧΚΜ7!Ν.&∗&!

;∗4∗!Ο&=;∋∗=Π+∋∗! )(∃!0(ΗΘ#∃!<=∋)(∃!#!4#4:+∗! )∗!;∗+2∗! Ρ&+Σ)∋;∗!=(! /∗+.#!Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−!)#!Υ&∃.∋Η(!Λ/ΤΥΜ1!

ς(∋(7! ΩΒΞΧ#4:+∗! )∗! /∗4∋.Ψ! /∗=∃&−.∋3∗! 2(+(! 0∗4#(ΗΘ#∃ ! )∗! ≅+∋:&=(−! ∀#=(−! Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−! Λ≅∀ΤΜ1! ς(∋(7!

Ω∃.ΠΙ∋∗!ΖΨ=∋∗+!=(!/∗−&4:∋(!<=∋3#+∃∋.[7!/(=)∋)(.∗!∋=)∋;()∗!2#−(!∀+#∃∋)Ψ=;∋(!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!(∗!2∗∃.∗!)#! Ρ&∋∴!

)∗!≅+∋:&=(−! ∀#=(−!Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−1! ς(∋(7!/(=)∋)(.∗! ∋=)∋;()∗!2#−∗!Χ∋=∋∃.>+∋∗! )(∃!Ε#−(ΗΘ#∃! ΩΒ.#+∋∗+#∃!2(+(! (!

−∋∃.(!)#!Ρ&Σ∴#∃!2(+(!(!;∗42∗∃∋Ηϑ∗!)∗!≅+∋:&=(−!Ω∃2#;∋(−!2(+(!∗!]Σ:(=∗1!ς(∋(7!∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+!;∗=3∋)()∗!)∗!ΑΤ=∃.∋.&.!

)#∃!ς(&.#∃! ⊥.&)#∃! Τ=.#+=(.∋∗=(−#∃!)#! −(! <=∋3#+∃∋.>!∀(=.Φ>∗=ΞΝ∃∃(∃!∀(+∋∃! ΤΤΑ! #!)(!<=∋3#+∃∋.>! /(#=! ,(∃∃#Ξ

0∗+4(=)∋#1! Γ+(=Η(7! ∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+! /∗=3∋)()∗! )∗! ](&.#+2(;Φ.! /#=.+#1! /(4:+∋) Ι#! <=∋3#+∃∋.[1! <_7! ∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+!

;∗=3∋)()∗! Ν∋ΒΞΧ(+∃#∋−−#! <=∋3#+∃∋.>Ξ! Γ+(=Η(7! ∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+! ;∗=3∋)()∗! ]Τ=∃.∋.&.! )⊥.&)#∃! ∀∗−∋.∋%&#∃! )Ν∋ΒΞ#=Ξ

∀+∗3#=;#!Ξ!Γ+(=Η(7!Χ#4:+∗!)(!Ν;()(4∋(!0(;∋∗=(−!)#!8#+#;Φ∗!)#!−(!Ν+Ι#=.∋=(7!∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+!)∗!???ΤΤ!/&+∃∗!

)#!8∋+#∋.∗!Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−!)(!α+Ι(=∋∴(Ηϑ∗! )∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!Ν4#+∋;(=∗∃! ΛαΩΝΜ7!/∗=Ο#+#;∋∃.(!=(!Κ∋−:#+.∗!Ν4()∗!

Χ#4∗+∋(−!]#;.&+#1!Ρ&=.∗!β!/∗4∋∃∃ϑ∗!)#!8∋+#∋.∗!Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−!)(!α+Ι(=∋∴(Ηϑ∗!)(∃!0(ΗΘ#∃!<=∋)(∃!Λ/8Τχ<0Μ1!

Κ#=#:+(7!∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+! /(.#)+Π.∋;∗!≅∋.&−(+! )#!8∋+#∋.∗! Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−!∀9:−∋;∗! )(!<=∋3#+∃∋)()#! Γ#)#+(−!)#!Χ∋=(∃!

Κ#+(∋∃!Λ<ΓΧΚΜ!#!/Φ#Ο#!)∗!8#2(+.(4#=.∗!)#!8∋+#∋.∗!∀9:−∋;∗7!∀+∗Ο#∃∃∗+!Ν)Ρ&=.∗!)(!∀∗=.∋ΟΣ;∋(!<=∋3#+∃∋)()#!

/(.δ−∋;(! )#! Χ∋=(∃! Κ#+(∋∃! Λ∀</! Χ∋=(∃Μ7! ∀+#∃∋)#=.#! #! Ο&=)()∗+! )∗! /#=.+∗! )#! 8∋+#∋.∗! Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−7!

/∗∗+)#=()∗+!)∗∃!;&+∃∗∃!)#!∀δ∃!Κ+()&(Ηϑ∗!)∗!/Ω8Τ0!Ξ!/#=.+∗!)#!Ω∃.&)∗∃!#4!8∋+#∋.∗!#!0#Ιδ;∋∗∃7!Χ#4:+∗!

Φ∗=∗+ΣΟ∋;∗!)(! Ν;()#4∋(!Χ∋=#∋+(! )#! ]#.+(∃!Υ&+Σ)∋;(∃7! Χ#4:+∗!)(! Ζ∗;∋>.>!Γ+(=Η(∋∃#!)#! 8+∗∋.!Τ=.#+=(.∋∗=(−!

ΛΖΓ8ΤΜ7!8∋+#.∗+! )∗! +(4∗! :+(∃∋−#∋+∗! )(!Τ=.#+=(.∋∗=(−! ](ε! Ν∃∃∗;∋(.∋∗=! ΛΤ]Ν!,+(∃∋−Μ7!8∋+#.∗+! ∀+#∃∋)#=.#! )∗!

Ν=&Π+∋∗!,+(∃∋−#∋+∗! )#!8∋+#∋.∗! Τ=.#+=(;∋∗=(−! ΛΝ,8ΤΜ7!Ζδ;∋∗! )(!0#4#+! #!Κ&∋4(+ϑ#∃! Ν)3∗Ι()∗∃!Ν∃∃∗;∋()∗∃!

Λ0φΚΜ7!

∀#%

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!∀∗−Σ.∋;(!)∗!Τ42>+∋∗!)∗!,+(∴∋−1!6ϕ!)#!4(+Η∗!)#!ηλ6ρ1!(+.∋Ι∗!ηγ61!∋=;∋∃∗∃!Τ1!ΤΤ!#!Τ?7!!

∀#&

!Ζ#Ι&=)∗!∗!∋=;∋∃∗!ΤΤΤ!)∗!(+.∋Ι∗!ηγ61!;(:#!(∗!Τ42#+()∗+!θΟ(∴#+!≅+(.()∗∃!)#!Ν−−∋(=Η(!∗ΟΟ#=∃∋3(1!#!)#Ο#=∃∋3(1!

)#!Ζ&:∃∋)∋∗1!#!/∗44#+;∋∗τ1!4(∃! θ−#3(=)∗Ξ∗∃!)#2∗∋∃! )#!;∗=;−&∋)∗∃!(∗! ;∗=Φ#;∋4#=.∗!)(! Ν∃∃#4:−>(!Κ#+(−1!

%&(=)∗! ∗! ∋=.#+#∃∃#1! #! ∃#Ι&+(=Η(! )∗! Ω∃.()∗! 2#+4∋..∋+#47! Ζ#! ∗∃! ≅+(.()∗∃! ;∗=;−&∋)∗∃! #4! .#42∗! )#! 2(∴!

#=3∗−3#+#4!;#∃∃ϑ∗1!∗&!.+∗;(! )#!≅∗++∋.∗+∋∗!)∗!Τ42#+∋∗1! ∗&!)#!∀∗∃∃#∃∃Θ#∃1!(!%&#! ∗!Τ42#+∋∗!.#=Φ(!)∋+#∋.∗1! =ϑ∗!

!∀#∃%&∋()∗#+(∃,)−.)(∗#/.#/)(.)0∗#)%0.(%∃1)∗%∃−#

#

!∀#∃%&∋()%∗+&,−&%∋(.−(/&%−&0∋(1∀0−%∀∗2&∋∀∗,3(1445(6789:7;8;3(<∋,=63( ∀=(>?3(≅∗∀(.−(>9>9(

(#!

(#!]⊥φ]:! /∋&%7?#∋−2!&∃! ς∋#7−(#%/#!(&! Ω#36;,−4&!4∃∗3#/<%4−&7!#ϑ#42/−1&7!#!&! #,#!&/∋−;2−2:!

#∗!7#2!&∋/−≅∃!α⊥:!&2/∃∋−(&(#!3&∋&!(#4,&∋&∋!&!≅2#∋∋&!#! ?&Λ#∋!&!3&Λ:!%∃∗#&∋!∃7!∗#∗;∋∃7!(∃!

+∃∋3∃! Υ−3,∃∗Π/−4∃! #! &≅#%/#7! 4∃%72,&∋#7:! ∗&%/#∋! ∋#,&ΝΟ#7! 4∃∗! 97/&(∃7! #7/∋&%≅#−∋∃7! #!

4#,#;∋&∋!/∋&/&(∃7

∀#∋

8!!

Υ&! Ω#1∃,2ΝΦ∃! (#! ]φβ_! &/∆! ∃! ?−∗! (&! Θ#≅2%(&! ε2#∋∋&! κ2%(−&,:! (∃−7! ∗∃(#,∃7!

4∃%7/−/24−∃%&−7! −∋Φ∃! ∃∋−#%/&∋! &! #7/∋2/2∋&! %∃∋∗&/−1&! ;∋&7−,#−∋&8! Α! +∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃! (#! ]φβα!

∗&%/#1#!#∗!72&!#77<%4−&!∃7!3∋−%453−∃7!∋#32;,−4&%∃7! ∗&7! 3∋∃42∋&! &3∋−∗∃∋&∋! 4∃∗! ∗&−∃∋!

4,&∋#Λ&!#!&;∋&%≅<%4−&!&7!∋#≅∋&7!Β2#!∃∋−#%/&∗!&!&ΝΦ∃!;∋&7−,#−∋&!%∃!4&∗3∃!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,8!

)#7/#!7#%/−(∃:! 7#2! &∋/−≅∃!γη!#7/&;#,#4#! Β2#! 4∃∗3#/#!&∃!ς∋#7−(#%/#! (&! Ω#36;,−4&!∗&%/#∋!

∋#,&ΝΟ#7!4∃∗!97/&(∃7!#7/∋&%≅#−∋∃7:!4#,#;∋&∋!/∋&/&(∃7!#!4∃%1#%ΝΟ#7!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&−7!∗#(−&%/#!

∋#?#∋#%(∃!(∃!+∃%≅∋#77∃!)&4−∃%&,!#!(#4,&∋&∋!&!≅2#∋∋&!∃2!?&Λ#∋!&!3&Λ!∗#(−&%/#!&2/∃∋−Λ&ΝΦ∃!

(∃!ς∃(#∋!∀#≅−7,&/−1∃

∀#(

8!Ρ!97/&(∃!)∃1∃:!∋#?,#/−(∃!%&!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!(#!]φβµ:!−%4,−%∃2=7#!%&!

(−∋#ΝΦ∃!(#!2∗!∗∃(#,∃!(−/&/∃∋−&,8!)#,&!3∋#1−&=7#:!3∃∋!#ϑ#∗3,∃:!∃!&∋/−≅∃!µβ:!Β2#!(#/#∋∗−%&!

7#∋!∃!ς∋#7−(#%/#! (&! Ω#36;,−4&! &!Ψ&2/∃∋−(&(#!723∋#∗&!(∃! 97/&(∃Ζ:! Β2#! Ψ(−∋−≅#!&!3∃,5/−4&!

−%/#∋%&! #! #ϑ/#∋%&:! 3∋∃∗∃1#! ∃2! ∃∋−#%/&! &! 3∃,5/−4&! ,#≅−7,&/−1&! (#! −%/#∋#77#! %&4−∃%&,! #!

723#∋−%/#%(#! &! Α(∗−%−7/∋&ΝΦ∃! (∃! ς&57Ζ

∀#)

8! Θ2&! ,#/∋&! &;∋&%≅−&! 2∗&! −%∃1&ΝΦ∃:! 4∃∗! &!

3∃77−;−,−(&(#! (#! 4∃%Β2−7/&7! 3&∋&! &! &Β2−7−ΝΦ∃! (#! /#∋∋−/Χ∋−∃78! )#77&! ,Χ≅−4&:! ∃! &∋/−≅∃! αν!

(#/#∋∗−%&!Β2#!Ψ∃!/#∋∋−/Χ∋−∃!?#(#∋&,!4∃∗3∋##%(#!∃7!/#∋∋−/Χ∋−∃7!(∃7!97/&(∃7!#!∃7!(−∋#/&∗#%/#!

&(∗−%−7/∋&(∃7! 3#,&! Ξ%−Φ∃:! 3∃(#%(∃! &4∋#74#∋! 4∃∗! %∃1∃7! /#∋∋−/Χ∋−∃7! Β2#! &! #,#! 1#%Ι&∗! &!

−%4∃∋3∃∋&∋=7#!3∃∋!&Β2−7−ΝΦ∃:!4∃%?∃∋∗#!&7!∋#≅∋&7!(∃!(−∋#−/∃!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,Ζ

∀∃∗

8!

+∃∗! ∃! ?−∗! (&! Θ#≅2%(&! ε2#∋∋&! κ2%(−&,! #! ∃! &(1#%/∃! (&! +∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃! (#! ]φαη:!

3∋∃42∋∃2=7#! ∋##Β2−,−;∋&∋! ∃7! 3∋−%453−∃7! ∋#,&/−1∃7! Η! &/2&ΝΦ∃! (∃! .∋&7−,! %&7! ∋#,&ΝΟ#7!

−%/#∋%&4−∃%&−7!4∃∗!∃7!%∃1∃7!1&,∃∋#7!(&!7∃4−#(&(#!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,8!)#77#!7#%/−(∃:!?∃−!#ϑ/−%/&!

&!3∃77−;−,−(&(#!(#!≅2#∋∋&7!(#!4∃%Β2−7/&:!3∋#1−7/&!%&!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!&%/#∋−∃∋:!4∃∗∃! −%(−4&!∃!

&∋/−≅∃!αν:!Β2#!(#/#∋∗−%&!Β2#!Ψ∃!.∋&7−,!7Χ!∋#4∃∋∋#∋Π!Η!≅2#∋∋&:!7#!%Φ∃!4∃2;#∋!∃2!7#!∗&,∃≅∋&∋!

∃!∋#42∋7∃!&∃! &∋;−/∋&∗#%/∃! ∃2! &∃7!∗#−∃7!3&45?−4∃7!(#! 7∃,2ΝΦ∃! (∃! 4∃%?,−/∃:!∋#≅2,&(∃7!3∃∋!

Χ∋≅Φ∃!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,!(#!7#≅2∋&%Ν&:!(#!Β2#! 3&∋/−4−3#ϖ!#! #∗!4&7∃! %#%Ι2∗!7#! #∗3#%Ι&∋Π!#∗!

!

∃#+ϑ∗!+(.∋Ο∋;()∗∃1! ∃#4!.#+#4! ∃∋)∗!(22+∗3()∗∃! 2#−(!Ν∃∃#4:−>(! Κ#+(−τ7!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗! ∀∗−Σ.∋;(!)∗! Τ42>+∋∗!)∗!

,+(∴∋−1!6ϕ!)#!4(+Η∗!)#!ηλ6ρ7!!

∀#∋

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!6ρ!)#!Ο#3#+#∋+∗!)#!ηλϖη1!(+.∋Ι∗!ρλ1!∋=;∋∃∗∃!κ1!η61!

ηι1!ηρ!#!ησ7!!

∀#(

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!ησ!)#!Ρ&−Φ∗!)#!ηϖιρ1!(+.∋Ι∗!ϕσ1!∋=;∋∃∗∃!ϕ1!σ1!ϖ!#!

ηγ7!Ν! /∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗! )#! ηϖιρ! ;Φ#Ι(!(! .+(.(+! )#! )#.(−Φ#∃!∋=&∃∋.()∗∃1!;∗4∗! (! =#;#∃∃∋)()#! )#!(&.∗+∋∴(Ηϑ∗! )∗!

∀+#∃∋)#=.#!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!2(+(!:+(∃∋−#∋+∗∃!(;#∋.(+#4!2#=∃ϑ∗1!#42+#Ι∗1!∗&!;∗4∋∃∃ϑ∗! +#4&=#+()∗∃!)#!Κ∗3#+=∗!

#∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗!Λ(+.∋Ι∗!ϕσ1!∋=;∋∃∗!ησΜ!∗&!)(!4(=&.#=Ηϑ∗!)(!+#2+#∃#=.(Ηϑ∗!:+(∃∋−#∋+(!Ρ&=.∗!β!Ζ(=.(!Ζ>!Λ(+.∋Ι∗!ηκσΜ7!!

∀#)

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!ηγ!)#!0∗3#4:+∗!)#!ηϖικ1!(+.∋Ι∗!κι7!!

∀∃∗

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!ηγ!)#!0∗3#4:+∗!)#!ηϖικ1!(+.∋Ι∗!ρζ7!!

1445(6789:7;8;!

!∀#∃%&∋()%∗+&,−&%∋(.−(/&%−&0∋(1∀0−%∀∗2&∋∀∗,3(1445(6789:7;8;3(<∋,=63(∀=(>?3(≅∗∀(.−(>9>9(

≅2#∋∋&!(#!4∃%Β2−7/&:!(−∋#/&!∃2! −%(−∋#/&∗#%/#:!3∃∋!7−!∃2!#∗! &,−&%Ν&!4∃∗!∃2/∋∃!97/&(∃Ζ+

∀∃!

8!

)∃! Μ∗;−/∃! (&7! &/−1−(&(#7! #ϑ#42/−1&7:! ∃! ς∋#7−(#%/#! (&! Ω#36;,−4&! 3∋#7#∋1∃2! 72&7!

4∃∗3#/<%4−&7!3&∋&!∗&%/#∋!∋#,&ΝΟ#7!4∃∗!97/&(∃7!#7/∋&%≅#−∋∃7!#!4#,#;∋&∋!/∋&/&(∃7:! (#4,&∋&∋!

&!≅2#∋∋&!#!?&Λ#∋!&!3&Λ!∗#(−&%/#!&2/∃∋−Λ&ΝΦ∃!(∃!+∃%≅∋#77∃!)&4−∃%&,

∀∃∀

8!!

Α!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!(#!]φηµ!#!&!9∗#%(&!+∃%7/−/24−∃%&,!%ν!]!(#!]φηφ!−%7/−/24−∃%&,−Λ&∋&∗!

∃! Ω#≅−∗#! κ−,−/&∋! −%7/&2∋&(∃! #∗! ]φηα

∀∃#

:! &/∋−;2−%(∃! #73#4−&,! −∗3∃∋/Μ%4−&! Η! (#?#7&! (&!

7#≅2∋&%Ν&!%&4−∃%&,! #! ∋#7/∋−%≅−%(∃!(−1#∋7∃7!(−∋#−/∃7! 3∃,5/−4∃7

∀∃∃

8!Α3#7&∋! (−77∃:! &7!%∃∋∗&7!

4∃%7/−/24−∃%&−7!(∃! 3#∋5∃(∃!%Φ∃!3∋∃∗∃1#∋&∗! ≅∋&%(#7!&,/#∋&ΝΟ#7!%∃! /∋&/&∗#%/∃!(∃!97/&(∃!

;∋&7−,#−∋∃!%&7!∋#,&ΝΟ#7!−%/#∋%&4−∃%&−7:!∗&%/#%(∃! &∃! ς∋#7−(#%/#! (&! Ω#36;,−4&! &7! ∗#7∗&7!

4∃∗3#/<%4−&7!3∋#1−7/&7!%&!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!&%/#∋−∃∋

∀∃%

8!

Ρ;7#∋1&=7#:! (#7/#! ∗∃(∃:! Β2#! &! /∋&(−ΝΦ∃! 4∃%7/−/24−∃%&,! ;∋&7−,#−∋&! /#∗! 7−(∃:! #∗!

≅∋&%(#! ∗#(−(&:! &! (#! (#/#∋∗−%&∋! 4∃∗3#/<%4−&7! ∋#,&/−1&7! &∃! #ϑ#∋454−∃! (&7! ∋#,&ΝΟ#7!

−%/#∋%&4−∃%&−7! 3#,∃! .∋&7−,8! Α77−∗:! ;∃&! 3&∋/#! (&7! 3∋#1−7Ο#7! #∗! ∗&/∆∋−&! (#! (−∋#−/∃!

−%/#∋%&4−∃%&,:!4∃%/−(&7!%&7! 4∃%7/−/2−ΝΟ#7! ;∋&7−,#−∋&7:! #7/Φ∃! 3∋#1−7/&7! #∗! (−73∃7−/−1∃7!Β2#!

(#/#∋∗−%&∗!&7!&/∋−;2−ΝΟ#7!(∃!ς∋#7−(#%/#!(&!Ω#36;,−4&!∃2!(&!Ξ%−Φ∃8!Α!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!ρ#(#∋&,!

(#!]φ⊥⊥!∗&%/∆∗!/&,!/∋&(−ΝΦ∃:!4∃∗∃!7#!∃;7#∋1&!%∃7!&∋/−≅∃7!]:!−%4−7∃7!Κ!#!ΚΚ

∀∃&

!#!⊥α:!−%4−7∃!

ϕΚΚ

∀∃∋

8!9%/∋#/&%/∃:!∃!&∋/−≅∃!αν!(&!+∃%7/−/2−ΝΦ∃!ρ#(#∋&,!(#!]φ⊥⊥!/∋&Λ!2∗!#,#∗#%/∃!−%∃1&(∃∋:!

3∃−7! (#74∋#1#! #∗! /#∋∗∃7! ∃;Ε#/−1∃7! ∃7! 3∋−%453−∃7! Β2#! ∋#≅#∗! ∃! .∋&7−,! %&7! 72&7! ∋#,&ΝΟ#7!

−%/#∋%&4−∃%&−7

∀∃(

8! +∃%7/−/24−∃%&,−Λ&=7#:! &77−∗:! ∃! 3∃7−4−∃%&∗#%/∃! ;∋&7−,#−∋∃! %&! #7?#∋&!

!

∀∃!

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!ηλ!)#!Ζ#.#4:+∗!)#!ηϖρσ1!(+.∋Ι∗!ρζ7!!

∀∃∀

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃!<=∋)∗∃!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!ηλ!)#!Ζ#.#4:+∗!)#!ηϖρσ1!(+.∋Ι∗!λκ1!∋=;∋∃∗∃!Τ!!

∀∃#

!Ω7!Ω7! ∀7! Υ9=∋∗+1! Ν∃!+#−(ΗΘ#∃! ∋=.#+=(;∋∗=(∋∃! =(! /∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)#!ηϖλλ! #! Ζ&(∃!/∗=∃#%&Ψ=;∋(∃!=(! ∀∗−Σ.∋;(!

ΩΒ.#+=(!,+(∃∋−#∋+(1!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)#!ηϖλλπ!α!,+(∃∋−!6γ!Ν=∗∃!8#2∗∋∃1!α∃!Ν−∋;#+;#∃!)(!Ε#)#4∗;+(.∋∴(Ηϑ∗1!∗−7!

η1! 6γγλ1! )∋∃2∗=Σ3#−! #4π! 2&:−∋;(;∗#∃χ#∃.&)∗∃Ξ−#Ι∋∃−(.∋3∗∃χ.∋2∗∃Ξ)#Ξ#∃.&)∗∃χ∗&.+(∃Ξ2&:−∋;(;∗#∃χ3∗−&4#Ξ∋Ξ

;∗=∃.∋.&∋;(∗Ξ)#Ξηϖλλχ+#−(;∗#∃Ξ∋=.#+=(;∋∗=(∋∃Ξ(∃Ξ+#−(;∗#∃Ξ∋=.#+=(;∋∗=(∋∃Ξ=(Ξ;∗=∃.∋.&∋;(∗Ξ)#ΞηϖλλΞ#Ξ∃&(∃Ξ

;∗=∃#%&#=;∋(∃Ξ=(Ξ2∗−∋.∋;(Ξ#Β.#+=(Ξ:+(∃∋−#∋+(!!(;#∃∃∗!#4π!6ϕχγλχ6γησ7!!

∀∃∃

!α!Ω∃.(.&.∗!)#! Ω∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗! Λ]#∋! =ζ! σ7ληϕ1! )#!ηϖ! )#! (Ι∗∃.∗! )#!ηϖλγΜ1!2∗+! #Β#42−∗1! ;∗=∃∋)#+(3(! ∃#+!)∗!

∋=.#+#∃∃#! )(! ∃#Ι&+(=Η(! =(;∋∗=(−! (! 2∗−Σ.∋;(!4∋Ι+(.δ+∋(! #! (! 2+#∃#=Η(! )#! #∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗∃! =∗! 2(Σ∃1! 2+∗∋:∋=)∗! ∗∃!

#∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗∃!()4∋.∋)∗∃! =∗!2(Σ∃!)#! 2(+.∋;∋2(+!)#! (.∋3∋)()#∃! )#!=(.&+#∴(! 2∗−Σ.∋;(!;∗4∗! 2(∃∃#(.(∃! #!2+∗.#∃.∗∃!

Λ(+.∋Ι∗!ηγκ1!∋=;∋∃∗!ΤΤΤΜ!#!2∗∃∃∋:∋−∋.(=)∗!∃&(!#Β2&−∃ϑ∗!=∗!;&+∃∗!)#!2+∗;#∃∃∗!Ρ&)∋;∋(−!θ)#∃)#!%&#!;∗=3#=∋#=.#!(∗!

∋=.#+#∃∃#!=(;∋∗=(−τ!Λ(+.∋Ι∗!σκΜ7!!

∀∃%

!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!Γ#)#+(.∋3(!)∗!,+(∃∋−!)#! ηϖσκ1!6ρ!)#! Ρ(=#∋+∗!)#! ηϖσκ1!;∗4!+#)(Ηϑ∗! )()(!2#−(!

Ω4#=)(!/∗=∃.∋.&;∋∗=(−!=ζ!η1!)#!ηκ!)#!∗&.&:+∗!)#!ηϖσϖ1!(+.∋Ι∗!λη1!∋=;∋∃∗∃!Τ?1!?1!?Τ!#!?ΤΤ7!!

∀∃&

!θ/∗42#.#! β! <=∋ϑ∗π! Τ! Ξ! 4(=.#+! +#−(ΗΘ#∃! ;∗4! Ω∃.()∗∃! #∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗∃! #! 2(+.∋;∋2(+! )#! ∗+Ι(=∋∴(ΗΘ#∃!

∋=.#+=(;∋∗=(∋∃ψ!ΤΤ!Ξ!)#;−(+(+!(!Ι&#++(!#!;#−#:+(+!(!2(∴τ7!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!Γ#)#+(.∋3(!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!γϕ!)#!

∗&.&:+∗!)#!ηϖλλ1!(+.∋Ι∗!6η1!∋=;∋∃∗∃!Τ!#!ΤΤ7!!

∀∃∋

!θ/∗42#.#!2+∋3(.∋3(4#=.#!(∗!∀+#∃∋)#=.#!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(π!Λ777Μ!ΤΤ!Ξ!4(=.#+!+#−(ΗΘ#∃!;∗4!Ω∃.()∗∃!#∃.+(=Ι#∋+∗∃!

#!(;+#)∋.(+!∃#&∃!+#2+#∃#=.(=.#∃!)∋2−∗4Π.∋;∗∃ψτ7!/∗=∃.∋.&∋Ηϑ∗!)(!Ε#29:−∋;(!Γ#)#+(.∋3(!)∗!,+(∃∋−1!γϕ!)#!∗&.&:+∗!

)#!ηϖλλ1!(+.∋Ι∗!λρ1!∋=;∋∃∗!ΤΤ7!!

∀∃(

θΝ!Ε#29:−∋;(!Γ#)#+(.∋3(!)∗!,+(∃∋−! +#Ι#Ξ∃#!=(∃!∃&(∃!+#−(ΗΘ#∃!∋=.#+=(;∋∗=(∋∃!2#−∗∃!∃#Ι&∋=.#∃!2+∋=;Σ2∋∗∃π!Τ!Ξ!

∋=)#2#=)Ψ=;∋(!=(;∋∗=(−ψ!ΤΤ!Ξ!2+#3(−Ψ=;∋(!)∗∃!)∋+#∋.∗∃!Φ&4(=∗∃ψ!ΤΤΤ! Ξ!(&.∗)#.#+4∋=(Ηϑ∗!)∗∃!2∗3∗∃ψ! Τ!Ξ!=ϑ∗Ξ

∋=.#+3#=Ηϑ∗ψ!!Ξ!∋Ι&(−)()#!#=.+#! ∗∃!Ω∃.()∗∃ψ!Τ!Ξ!)#Ο#∃(! )(!2(∴ψ!ΤΤ!Ξ! ∃∗−&Ηϑ∗!2(;ΣΟ∋;(!)∗∃!;∗=Ο−∋.∗∃ψ!ΤΤΤ! Ξ!

+#29)∋∗!(∗! .#++∗+∋∃4∗!#!(∗! +(;∋∃4∗ψ!Τ?! Ξ!;∗∗2#+(Ηϑ∗! #=.+#!∗∃! 2∗3∗∃!2(+(! ∗!2+∗Ι+#∃∃∗!)(!Φ&4(=∋)()#ψ!?! Ξ!